Advertisement
Hi. I have a Sony Vaio notebook (model VGN-SZ120P) and the battery is in its final death throes.
The computer is nearly two years old, Sony doesn't even sell the battery online anymore.
I'm gagging over Sony's $199.99 price tag for a replacement, but nervous about picking up a cheaper version.
The Sony replacement specs are 11.1V / 5200 mAh.
I've found other cheaper knock-offs for under $100 with specs 11.1V / 4400 mAh.
Is it worth it to get the more expensive one? Why or why not? Does the difference in mAh matter in any way other than length of time it holds a charge?
Would it be more worth it to just get two of the cheaper ones, which still turns out cheaper than the single Sony replacement battery?
Not much activity in this tribe, I hope someone is around to help.
Cheers!
The computer is nearly two years old, Sony doesn't even sell the battery online anymore.
I'm gagging over Sony's $199.99 price tag for a replacement, but nervous about picking up a cheaper version.
The Sony replacement specs are 11.1V / 5200 mAh.
I've found other cheaper knock-offs for under $100 with specs 11.1V / 4400 mAh.
Is it worth it to get the more expensive one? Why or why not? Does the difference in mAh matter in any way other than length of time it holds a charge?
Would it be more worth it to just get two of the cheaper ones, which still turns out cheaper than the single Sony replacement battery?
Not much activity in this tribe, I hope someone is around to help.
Cheers!
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Aftermarket Replacement Laptop Battery Question
Wed, May 21, 2008 - 9:33 PMGiven the recent battery debacle involving the devices overheating and occasionally catching fire, you may not have a choice in the matter. However, if you're going to shell out that kind of cash, I would make sure that you are getting a new battery and not a used or RPL battery. Ebay can be a good source for replacement batteries, but then you run into the possibility of inheriting someone else's problems all over again. Unless you are very attached to the system, you may just want to take that $199 and put it towards a new laptop honestly. There are some pretty decent rigs out there in the $600-$700 range. -
-
Re: Aftermarket Replacement Laptop Battery Question
Thu, May 22, 2008 - 11:54 PMThanks. Not sure why I don't have a choice in the matter? Can you elaborate? Kind of seems based on the recommendation to use the $199 and put it towards the new laptop that you mean I should get the Sony battery. I'm definitely getting a new batter and not a new machine! I'm a graphic/web designer and the machine I have now cost nearly $2K and is less than two years old. I don't need a clunky machine to cruise the internet with!
What I need is a MAC. *sigh* -
-
Re: Aftermarket Replacement Laptop Battery Question
Fri, May 23, 2008 - 12:49 AMAs far as choices go, I would tend to believe that yours are limited regarding the battery. Going with a refurb/rpl battery or with a cheap alternate could very well result in a device that slags your rig. If the price is sufficiently less and you want to go with the cheaper device, I would make some persistent and clear inquiries regarding the safety of the battery and any associated risks and guarantees regarding how compatible the battery is with your rig. Lastly, if you do decide to purchase the alternative, use a credit card. Credit cards have better built in customer protection than a check, money order, or Paypal for that matter.
Given the potential for a fire prone battery, I would tend to go with a new one. Which is why I think your choices are limited. It is, however, worth looking into, and further it can't possibly hurt to check the manufacturer's website of your laptop and see if your rig is one the systems that was affected to begin with. -
-
Re: Aftermarket Replacement Laptop Battery Question
Fri, May 23, 2008 - 8:05 PMTHANK YOU!!! Brilliant response, exactly what I was looking for. I checked out the Sony fire hazards and my machine is not one of the ones affected. I think that perhaps it might be worth putting out the money for a new Sony battery rather than one of the knock offs, based on what you said and my general gut feeling that it's safer both in avoiding something going wrong and because if something does go wrong I'd have more of a case using their battery in their computer.
Thanks again. -
-
Re: Aftermarket Replacement Laptop Battery Question
Sat, May 24, 2008 - 2:28 AMNo problem at all. Like I said before though - make sure that they state the battery unit you are purchasing is Brand New and not a refurbished battery. All too often end users purchase what they think is a new part for their X years old rig only to find out that they were sold a refurb. Normally this isn't a huge concern with two notable exceptions: Laptop batteries and HDD's.
I'm glad I was able to help.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Aftermarket Replacement Laptop Battery Question
Wed, December 17, 2008 - 4:20 AMI can also give a good reason:
You bought Sony. Sony ANYTHING costs about 4x what everyone else will pay. I'm not trying to knock your rig, but that's the onest truth. I used to have a Vaio. It was in the shop 3x in the first year, 2x in one week for repairs.
2.5 years ago I decided to get another laptop have going without for a long time. My Vaio didn't even last 18 months. I went with dell this time, and I will say that I will never buy from anyone else for a laptop. After 2.5 years of heavy use this thing still runs like the day i got it, and the battery has given me no problems and still holds a great charge.
Replacement batteries are cheap. You can also get extended life batteries, direct from dell for fair pricing, and there is no lack of after market brands to choose from that are 100% reliable and trustworthy. When I went shopping for Sony parts, I found the selection limited, and for the same size battery the Sony was 5x more and aftermarket 3x more than the same rated Volts and Amps for say, a compaq. Why would something with teh same output cost so much more? Becaus eit's sony.
Also- Dell puts a little external push button to show you remaining life.
Anyway.... last week I priced a new laptop cause I thought I blew mine up with a little water (dew sensor did it's job and i'm typing on it right now, just neede dto sit out over night, yet ANOTHER reason to buy) and for an Inpriron e1525 (upgrade from thsi one) you can get a loaded system witha fast Core 2 Duo, 2 gigs ram, 160 gig HD, and all the trimmings for around...
$650
Yes, $650 for a new dell laptop.
So, something to think about, you'd have 1/3 of the cost for a brand new system (and thats' with the true life high end HD display model) instead of a battery.
The irony is that when I tried to get my laptop fixed, Sony's repair policy is either $189 or $790 flat rate, depending on what's wrong with it. It went trhough two power supplies the first year, so it as either that or the mobo went, either way, too much.
New Dell laptop mobo's go for around $150 incidentally.
--S