Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

topic posted Wed, August 27, 2008 - 8:36 PM by  Unsubscribed
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
Spin off on another thread... but this topic is one that I;ve mulled over and worked out for YEARS. I'm quite at peace with it now, but i remember right after coming out it was fodder for issues. So lets discuss this.


From my perspective and In my shoes, i've seen a lot of "tension" shall i say between the obviously queer and the "straight acting, masculine" males...as if theres a totem pole... and your worth or sexuality is dependent on how well you pass. Through time, I see in far more grey textured manner than i did when i was, say 18. When i was in high school in the closet of course you didn't want to associate with the obvious queers.... they got picked on.... and they were "weak". That was the H.s. mindset ... that i see carried on by some into adulthood but in varying degrees. I don't know how many times i've heard bottoms refered to in derogatory terms. Bottoms who know are just bootoms.. i think we all do it.. it's something of an IN Joke it seems but underneath it carries the idea that femininity with your masculinity is.... wrong. you're weak. You are a siisy...which leads us to the cherished masculine male... the TOP... the married guy fantasy...the frat house fantasy... It's a part of the upper fabric of the gay experience.

So, at 25, I meet guys who are flaming fags.... some of whom are dear friends, who have to fend off a backlash from more masculine men (not all but those who find it necessary to actually be mean...and work within a pecking order). or the other way around. I have been in the past called on my masculinity... (gosh i could really go into that...but on another forum) ... it doesn't bother me anymore... just like it doesn't offend me if a guy is a complete queen. More, it does bother me that for some there is a totem pole, amongst adult gay men, that feels like high school...and a ditch in embracing the varying degrees of queers (not that you have to DATE or FUCK them). It seems futile. and the entire idea of straight acting is laughable.

I notice that men who are under the radar gay, are naturally masculine because... hey they were brought up in the woods... or in blue collar families. Those are men who happen to be gay and don't do gay things... and they are just as apt to be bottom pigs as much as the hairdresser with low rise jeans and purple tank top is... (and even HE can be someones top). I'm ranting but.... those are my ideas and experiences.
posted by:
Unsubscribed
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

    Fri, August 29, 2008 - 7:14 PM


    I agree with you, Mad Jack......as so often happens. ;)

    It's all so fluid and subjective at times too----
    In one situation I find myself hearing a friend refer to me as "soooo butch, so 'masculine'", referring to me as if I were the epitome of masculinity (sometimes said flatteringly, sometimes not so much.....).
    A week later.........or five minutes later, someone is joking about what a "big fag" I am.
    The truth is that I am....both.

    I came to detest gay male chat rooms in no small part due to the emphasis on, or should I say the _demand for_ some ridiculous, exaggerated, caricature of "masculinity", and the rude profiles & intros that began with "no fems!". By the time the queens were putting "str8-acting only!" into their profiles and wish lists, I knew it was time for me to go....though I'm more often perceived as a heterosexual male than a gay one. I just don't care for that whole "tone"....... .
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

      Fri, August 29, 2008 - 8:38 PM
      Gay male chat rooms and craigslists ads can be downright D.U.M.B and most of the men with highest expectations and prerequisites don't have any of those that they list...which is common. But come on.

      I still sometimes grapple with the issue when I meet a guy online who assumes i should be this Butch black guy with all the "bro's" put into it and i'm not. I'm soft spoken, and polite but then again I'm not a ... "queen"... I'm just myself...and it took me a long time to be fine with that and not feel as if i have to play to anyones fantasy. And being that i'm 25, and 5'9 ... Guys sort of want to place me as bottom or something because i'm not this overly masculine character... I don't know... it's odd.
      • Re: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

        Sat, August 30, 2008 - 11:53 AM

        <<<when I meet a guy online who assumes i should be this Butch black guy with all the "bro's" put into it and i'm not>>>


        LOL. I understand.
        In an episode of "Six Feet Under", the then-16 years old or so character Claire was talking to Keith, the black guy who was partnered with her brother David. I think the two had just gotten together at that point. Keith voiced a similar thing to Claire, re most gay guys' assumptions and expectations of him. Claire immediately got it (which surprised Keith), and said something along the lines of "yeah, they all want you to be like this Big Black Sex Top, I bet".
        At the time, it was a funny thing to say on semi-mainstream television.

        ;)
  • Re: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

    Mon, September 15, 2008 - 8:52 PM


    Waaaa. How can it be that we lost Mad Jack----- who is now another grey "unsubscribed" head?
    His posts were so insightful and interesting.
    :(
    The first person I've felt I would actually really _miss_ when they left Tribe.

    Sorry for being off-topic here.
    :0
  • Genderfucking, was: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

    Wed, September 17, 2008 - 8:01 AM
    In our faerie households, we we often into sending up the associations. For example, we kept our
    plumbing and electrical tools in pink and purple plastic kits. On one occasion, as a household member
    was going out to the bars in leather drag (yes, it's drag, too) we complemented the black outfit with a simple string of
    pearls, always in good taste...
  • Re: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

    Tue, February 24, 2009 - 8:20 PM
    Very well put. Throughout my life I have either been "too masculine" or haven't been "feminine enough". I'm a somewhat masculine man but on the otherhand, I like being seduced and like men who also like to be secuced.

    I like masculine men but not ones who try to bold you over with their brand of masculinity. I like feminine men but not the ones who pretend to be girls.

    I'm not a "straight acting" gay man. I'm just a man who appears to be straight that has certain affinities toward men. On the otherhand, I also enjoy the company of women.

    I'm also not "out". Not because being gay has it's political foibles, but I don't agree with much of the controvercial agendas of main-stream gays caught up in this political correctness and the back-lash of and from the public at large and even within the gay community.

    I want to keep people out of my bedroom and I can't do that when everyone in the gay community expects me to either have a butch or fem lover or expect me to be a top or bottom. I don't "fit" into this and prefer to "not be out" so I don't have to justify who I am. So I guess I fit this application; I'm gay but not 'gay'.
  • ben
    ben
    offline 7

    Re: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

    Tue, March 17, 2009 - 12:02 PM
    AS A HAPPILY MARRIED GUY WHO LOVES TO FUCK AND BE FUCKED BY OTHER MEN , I DO NOT FIT THE "GAY" STEROETYPE. MY WIFE ACCEPTS MY GUY FRIENDS AND LOVES THEM AS MUCH AS I DO, JUST NOT IN QUITE THEWAY I DO! THINK THE EMPHASIS SHOULD BE ON PLEAQSURE NOT SOME WEIRD SYSTEM CATEGORISING MEN ON WHAT THEY LIKE TO DO. THINK THAT IS A IDEA FROM THE ST8 COMMUNITY. BY THE WAY ,WE STILL GET FLAK FROM THE 'GAY' COMMUNITY FOR BEING BI-SEXUAL. JUST SAD.
  • Re: Masculine vs. Feminine "traits"

    Wed, October 28, 2009 - 2:40 PM
    Y'know, for every masculine trait there's a feminine trait to go with it. Hot damn. For every beer I have there's a fancy liquor I'd actually like to try. For every punk rock band there's a Japanese girl singing about love and giant robots beating the shit outta things. For every giant robot and hyperviolent movie, there's a sweet, soulful, indie flick. For all my lack of muscles, there's my gung-ho attitude to use them. For every outward, immature act there's a reserved, shy one. For every girl I hold close (platonically, of course) there's a guy I want to hold just as close, and for every guy I high-five, there's a chick I do the secret man-hand-shake. For every faggot thing I've done, there's a douchebag moment right around the corner. Bipolar? Perhaps. But the gray areas are where I'd rather be.