If you disagree, let them know

topic posted Fri, February 13, 2009 - 10:59 PM by  Shara
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
From the the University of Nevada, Reno's newspaper:
nevadasagebrush.com/blog/200...cks-zest/

Album Review: Tahoe band lacks zest
By Julian Rhodes
Tuesday, Feb. 10, 2009 @ 2:17 am

Jam bands that mix funk, rock, reggae and other genres are all about a good time. The String Cheese Incident, Phish and The Grateful Dead top this genre with fun vibes and groovy concerts. But South Lake Tahoe’s beloved Blue Turtle Seduction lack the originality of any of the above mentioned bands on their third album, “13 Floors.”

The first song, “What’s My Name?” takes an MXPX-like riff and rides the guitar into a corny harmonica solo before jumping back on the pop-punk guitars once again. Over these instrumentals, the whole band sang simultaneously in a strange singsong manner, much like the end of an episode of “Whose Line Is It Anyway?” The two-minute track could not have ended soon enough.

“Antidote” came next, but did little to remedy the lingering annoyance from the previous song. Instead, a sort of Beach-Boys-meets-Blues-Traveler ballad ensued. Violins and harmonicas kept the song from bridging into surf rock, but bouncy guitars kept the song right on edge. With an odd combination of genres, the song barely escapes blandness with a fairly entertaining guitar solo in the last minute.

“Stop Drop and Roll” is another strange combination of genres, with a blend of The Cure and Modest Mouse, plus a hint of Sublime to suffice. But the cheesy theatrics of combining such dissimilar sounds is intensified with a cliché chorus, in which vocalist Jay Seals sings, “Stop Drop and Roll/I’m doing my best not to explode.”

“Perfect Gentleman” and “Rome” follow, both equally lackluster in originality and execution.

The former begins with a sample of what sounds like a Tamagotchi before stumbling into a modern day “Kokomo” (The Beach Boys). A pseudo-rap near the end of the song plunges the nail into the coffin of this track.

“Rome,” level five of the “13 Floors,” picks up like a backyard hoedown. Southern twang, a crazy harmonica and crashing drums make this song seem better than the last. But all hopes are dashed the minute the vocals kick in. An exaggerated gruff returns to cliché with lyrics like, “There isn’t really anything left to do/ but to wander back home. / So go ahead, take a leap of faith / cause all roads lead to Rome.”

“Foot by Foot,” “Castaway,” “White Flags” and a couple more songs fill the middle of this album with more funky country rock, splicing genres and committing crimes against humanity along the way. With instrumentals almost as forgettable as the lyrics, the end of these “13 Floors” cannot be reached soon enough.

Nearing the end of the album, “El Camino” is fast-paced and mean, sounding like a Flogging Molly song but without the Irish. Of course, a song about an El Camino would not be complete without car sound effects and some Spanish lyrics.

The last song on the album, “Roses and Big Belt Buckle” is mostly a 13-minute instrumental with only a few lyrics here and there. This song by itself sums up the whole album. While a jam band is supposed to be fun and experimental, the sound of Blue Turtle Seduction is at its best when separated and focused – and without any vocals.

Strange instrumental combinations and genre copycatting plague this album all the way to its inevitable doom. In the end, “13 Floors” is just 13 too many.

Julian Rhodes can be reached at jrhodes@nevadasagebrush.com.
posted by:
Shara
SF Bay Area
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: If you disagree, let them know

    Sat, February 14, 2009 - 1:45 PM
    Like ass holes we all have opinions so I don't think writing letters disagreeing really makes any difference. Also publicity comes in many forms so some might check out bts just to see if this is true. The reasons this guy mentions for not liking bts is why I like them so much because they are different and the reason I don't like bands like ALO which for me equals boredom.
    Peace
    • Re: If you disagree, let them know

      Mon, February 16, 2009 - 10:36 AM
      Goodness I dont think I can handle reading this right now. I just saw the best BTS show ever up in Nev. City and my heart almost exploded.....dont want this article to kill my buzz......just yet. Soon....
      • Re: If you disagree, let them know

        Mon, February 16, 2009 - 5:20 PM
        Who cares about this ametuer writer and what he thinks, hes reviewing something he obvoiusly doesnt understand and a vibe he doesnt even like or enjoy......so who cares? Its not like it was a jambase article or in Rolling Stone, or its not like in some big SF publication. its just someones lame attempt to not like something. Posting it on tribe is almost like rubbing salt in the wound.

        I like to consider myself a well established 37 year old music fanatic, and 13 Floors didnt leave my car stereo all summer. Hmmmm....maybe its cuz I enjoy that style of music and understand BTS on a live level and vibe with their personality?
        • Re: If you disagree, let them know

          Mon, February 16, 2009 - 5:29 PM
          Heres what I commented: "This writer tries to be slick by adding little creative quotes that attempt to give his opinion some girth, but overall he fails, and comes across as shallowly listening, and judging too soon without introspective. This writer has obviously not experienced the band much, nor does he enjoy the turtle soup, or understand the true personality of this band and the void in the music community that they fill with their unusual yet catchy musings. Not everyone can get it, but not everyone can write a critical article that holds value, either.
          Although I found 13 Floors to be a little bleached out, the creativity, songwriting, heartfelt interesting lyrics, and kooky loving vocals kept this CD in my car all summer long. "

Recent topics in "Blue Turtle Seduction"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
BTS plays NOR NOR CAL. cheez geezr 0 November 16, 2009
Setlist archive!! KC dan 0 November 5, 2009
Blue Turtles helping Sea Turtles!! Shara 2 October 10, 2009
New & Recent Shows- LMA Downloads now available!! Shara 1 September 28, 2009