Advertisement
Being female and having a girl brain - which I most definitely do - and because we've been talking about what it is to be a woman in science and female culture, I thought it might interest the other brain geeks here to discuss this. I'm entirely open to it being discussed by the men in the tribe and having male perspectives on these matter too :-)
One of the very key understandings that scientific studies have offered is that there are biological differences in how women physically respond in social situations and how our brains work. One particular study that I think is of great importance is the difference in how women and men respond to stress - with the understanding that there is diversity amongst both and a general fluidity and not some cut and dried division between the sexes. I think that the tend and befriend response (as different from the fight or flight response) benefits both men and women but is particularly important in women's lives and to our sense of well being.
www.anapsid.org/cnd/gender/tendfend.html
One of the very key understandings that scientific studies have offered is that there are biological differences in how women physically respond in social situations and how our brains work. One particular study that I think is of great importance is the difference in how women and men respond to stress - with the understanding that there is diversity amongst both and a general fluidity and not some cut and dried division between the sexes. I think that the tend and befriend response (as different from the fight or flight response) benefits both men and women but is particularly important in women's lives and to our sense of well being.
www.anapsid.org/cnd/gender/tendfend.html
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Thu, October 22, 2009 - 12:47 PMAn interesting study about the difference in ability to read and identify emotions...
www.sciencedaily.com/release...5133.htm -
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Fri, October 23, 2009 - 4:03 AM...and then there was the man, a scientist, who told me that he had "a woman's brain" and that was the reason we could converse so well. I dunno.... -
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Fri, October 23, 2009 - 8:18 AMI have no idea if that particular man has a female brain but certainly it is a natural variation - people who are transgender are in exactly this situation. Their brain is one gender and the rest of their body looks like the other gender. I also think there's a great deal of fluidity, it's not a black or white thing for many people though there are people who are extremely male or female. None of this is a judgment value on my part, it's just another interesting facet of being human and why we need to leave lots of room for neurodiversity. -
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Fri, October 23, 2009 - 8:47 AMAfter reading both the study and the report on the study, methinks the reporter put a lot of her own opinion in the interpretation of the study.
That aside, I hope this leads to "science" re-doing any studies on all things brainy that until now only looked at male minds. I would have thought that before now we all realized the significant mental differences between the genders. But apparently not. -
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Fri, October 23, 2009 - 12:51 PMAnne - Thanks for participating, please keep in mind that being hostile to or dismissive of science isn't okay in this tribe, though being critical and/or discussing biases and bad science is (but then it's important to explain what your criticism is or reservations are otherwise it comes across as a general hostility to science and the scientific method). This may not be your intent, but putting "science" in quotations marks is making you look like you have an anti-science bias that isn't appropriate to this tribe. As does the rest of that sentence (along with revealing that you don't really follow neuro or cognitive science). This tribe is intended to be a refuge from the constant trolling of science tribes on tribe - please respect that. It's certainly okay if you're not an expert or this is a new area of interest to you but troll-like anti-science behavior where you're just being disparaging towards science from a place of ignorance isn't. It's certainly okay not to know things - we're all here to share and learn new things, as well as toss our own ideas around and have some fun - but the idea here is to share our knowledge and ideas with respect for the scientific method and an interest in neuro and cognitive science. I was very clear about this with you before you joined, please be respectful and true to your word.
It's also important to keep things in context. The person who wrote the article was really creating a narrative around how this research came about and explaining it in laymans terms. It's a good article when taken within that context - though you are, of course, free to disagree and explain what exactly you find problematic about it and what your own thoughts are about the study that differ. One reason why I posted it is it gives an insight into how having more women in science - bringing female culture into the lab - influences science. What seems obvious to you may not be as obvious as you believe it to be - for instance, someone can have a penis and a female brain, or a vagina and a male brain. Things are not as black and white as they often seem to the lay person. The reason I called this thread "female culture and girl brains" is that culture isn't the same as neurobiology, though nature and nurture are intertwined. You are quite welcome to share your own theories here but please base them in science rather than simply making negative and anti-science commentary. You're also welcome to share your subjective beliefs or observations but don't expect them to be accepted as more than a subjective perspective. And, as I warned you when you joined, I really don't have much patience for people who join this tribe and agree to respect it's basic premise and then start doing things like putting the word science into quotation marks. If you want to play that game, there are other science tribes that allow for it. -
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Sun, October 25, 2009 - 8:18 AMMy friend is neither transgender nor gay. He is a normal, heterosexual guy. But indeed, one day we both did this psychocological test that checked whether your way of thinking was male or female or something like that, and he came out somewhere in the middle, pretty much like he had told me. (I was pretty close to that too) -
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Mon, October 26, 2009 - 7:03 AMCanela - There are a lot of pseudoscientific "gender" tests out there, they're pretty much just entertainment. They may indicate something about enculturation and communication style - and something about the self-image of people who answer the questions, keeping in mind that people's self image isn't always aligned with how they present to others. Ultimately though, that's not the same thing as what I'm talking about. -
-
Re: Female culture and girl brains...
Tue, October 27, 2009 - 3:40 AMYeah, I know. The linguistic guys have tested that too.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-