Advertisement
I'm making vegetable soup today and have several beef bones that have boiled overnight - is it ok to give them to my dogs? They are smallish joint bones, and just the right size for my girls.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Bones?
Sat, October 17, 2009 - 10:11 AMI've always been told that cooked bones tend to splinter and the shards are dangerous.
Now I'm going to have to find sources to back up my supposition ... -
-
Re: Bones?
Sat, October 17, 2009 - 10:17 AMHere ya go:
answers.yahoo.com/question/index
www.ahimsarescuefoundation.org/bones.htm
www.howtodothings.com/pets-an...one.html
Lots more when you google "bones for dogs cooked or raw" -
-
Re: Bones?
Sat, October 17, 2009 - 4:34 PMNever even thought of "googling" it - thank you very much! -
-
Re: Bones?
Sat, October 17, 2009 - 4:41 PM'Googling' is the answer to most of my questions.
One rule I have with it though is if I'm not familiar with the source, I look for at least two concurring opinions -
-
Re: Bones?
Mon, October 19, 2009 - 1:27 PMit is interesting seeing one person after another confirming that it is "100% correct" to not give the dog cooked bones.
for what its worth, i have given my dog raw and cooked bones. he has chipped his teeth on cow joints. he has eaten too many beef ribs raw and pooped the chards, i never give him more than one rib now, and it gets digested. i once gave him a bone that was cut sharply by the butcher, and he did have some bleeding. that was scarey, but it was only one poop and he was okay by evening. i have given my dog some cooked bones. when i do this i am mindful of what the bone looks like. like a cooked lamb neck for example - i will still give him a joint or two or three. no more than that. and it has digested well. i have also on occasion given him chicken bones, which totally freaks people out. like i will give him one or two cooked chicken bones. DEFINITELY NOT the very pointy bone in the leg!! but the bone goes down fine and is a good treat. i have also given him cooked and raw chicken necks and they have been fine for his size and digestion.
i have lived on farms and next door to a country butcher - so i haven't always had complete control over what bones my dog has gotten. he does have a very good digestion. i think this is from a good puppy diet, lots of exercise and not an overbred breed.
-
-
Re: Bones?
Fri, October 30, 2009 - 10:27 AMZip,
I hear you, but I think you've just been lucky... Cooked bones impacted in a dog - not fun - bleeding stomachs, poop - not so much.
I only give my dogs raw knuckle and marrow bones....and raw chicken or turkey necks. They love these... Other than that, it's just not worth the hassle worry. -
-
Re: Bones?
Sat, October 31, 2009 - 1:26 PMHi Double Jenn
i don't think it has just been luck.
i know my dog and keep an eye him - so that i have really seen how what he eats is processed.
i agree for most people, and possibly most breeds, it is not worth the risk.
but there are people/experts who would say that a dog ALWAYS needs to eat the same foods. that a dog is better off eating plastic instead of raw bones. that a dog should NEVER eat chicken bones.
and it was the "100%" part that i wanted to counter with my own experience and observation.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Bones?
Wed, October 28, 2009 - 8:44 PMummm, yeah,
re:
>>have been the only single food item that guarantees a dog will have excellent health.
after a statement like that, I can't believe anything the "doctor" says. Terms like 'guarantees excellent health' is a phrase I'd expect to hear on a late-night infomercial trying to sell his garbage, not coming from a real doctor or real dog lover.
Haven't been on tribe for a while. Glad I came back this week. thanks for all the fun. -
-
Re: Bones?
Fri, November 6, 2009 - 1:57 PMthats interesting about the people who say to always give
the dog the same things to eat,,,I've heard it also with horses,,,
however,,,I usually always have 3 to 5 dogs and I rarely get the
same bag of food twice in a row,,,I tend to give them varieties
and when I can I cook them yams and stuff,,
also i always change horse feed around and in twenty five years I've
not had colics,,,a lot of people that are nervous about the food also
make the animals nervous in other ways,
a nearby gelsons has bones for dogs for a dollar a bag with 3 to 4 bones,,,
the dogs love them, i've never had a problem and their teeth are clean
best regards -
-
Re: Bones?
Fri, November 6, 2009 - 5:49 PMMy dog has been eating raw bones every day for the past 10 years. Lamb neck pieces, beef knuckle portions, but mostly raw chicken bones. He hasn't eaten commercial dog food since he was a year old. He eats a variety of different vegetables...he gets bored with the same thing so I switch it up fairly frequently.....he even eats live rodents when he can catch them. He just had his annual wellness exam including a senior baseline blood test and everything tested out beautifully. My vet said that he is the poster boy for raw feeding, he looks so great! He's almost 11 and is livelier than many 7 year olds.
I used to believe the old tales of commercial dog food only, never change the diet, yadda yadda yadda. I admit, Pip has been a guinea pig, but he is proving to me that the old tales from the dog food manufacturers whispered into vets ears, promising great profits, are wrong.
I have not had to use any form of flea control on him, I don't give him heart worm preventative(tests negative always), it's been years since he's had any of the "annual" vaccines, and he's never had to go in for a dental scraping. He has a strong immune system, no arthritis and is as healthy as the proverbial horse.
I am sold..I will never feed another dog of mine kibble. Sometimes I also sound like an infomercial, but it's only because I have seen the results for myself and am so psyched about it all. At least I know I have nothing to profit from in saying all that I say. It's all free and the ones who truly benefit from it are you and your dog. -
-
Re: Bones?
Fri, November 6, 2009 - 5:58 PMIn regards to cooked bones...as a general rule, cooked bones are a big no-no. However, a friend of my brothers' used to bring by spare rib bones to feed to my bro's pit bull. If the bones are cooked to the point where they are soft (chicken or pork), they aren't quite as dangerous, but still not recommended.
Pip did steal and eat 2/3 of a cooked turkey leg once and did live to tell about it, but I was very nervous for him for 24 hours afterward...thankfully it all went through fine. -
-
Re: Bones?
Sun, November 8, 2009 - 2:56 AMThe safest bet is raw bones. I stopped giving my 17 year old lab bones when she broke a tooth on one at the age of 15. Having bones to chew on before that helped to maintain great oral hygiene. Her teeth have always been sparkling white, with no signs of gum disease or odor. In her first 15 years, her teeth were only cleaned once. When she stopped getting bones, I started cleaning them twice per year.
She has all of her teeth, except the one that she broke.
If you give your dog bones, remember that many dogs like to bury them. They often dry out while buried, and can become brittle just like a cooked bone. So, you might consider supervision of bone chewing. -
-
Re: Bones?
Sun, November 8, 2009 - 8:56 AMIt's always a good idea to supervise your dog when they are eating bones
-
Re: Bones?
Fri, November 13, 2009 - 9:04 AMMy dogs love raw bones. I've also heard not to give them the leg bones of large ruminants, like cows, because they are too dense and can break teeth.
Riley has a hard time with bones now because he had to have both upper premolars removed after breaking them on nectarine pits. Yeah, I know he's not supposed to eat those, and we tried fencing the tree off, but the dog that won't go through a door that isn't open *all the way* dug under the fence and crawled through to get to the fruit tree. Unfortunately it was a very young dwarf so he could just pick them off the tree.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-