I finally had a chance to watch through this DVD, and was so excited by it that I had to post this review on Amazon. I know this is pretty long after the release, but I'm hoping others find it useful as well.
====
I became interested in Puela Lunaris's DVDs through World Dance New York, which is better known for its bellydance instructional videos. And while Lunaris has done work on the Zambra (the style of flamenco most closely associated with oriental dance) it is important to note that this video has nothing whatsoever to do with bellydance. In fact, the sevillanas are not even flamenco. They are an old, very strictly structured Spanish social dance which is sometimes performed in flamenco shows, but is also done socially in Spain. This DVD not only introduces the dance, but does an excellent job at showing how it can be performed alone, in a pair in a relaxed, social manner, and in a more showy performance style with fans.
The good:
As much as I generally do not like choreographies, this is the dance for them, since every sevillana is the same. The first choreo section is an extremely lengthy breakdown of all the movements necessary for all four sections of the sevillana dance. Lunaris is painstaking in demonstrating the steps, repeating them many times over, and then adding arms. There is instruction on posture, arm movement and placement, arm variations, the different styles of hand floreos.
Lunaris often also shows variations that can be introduced, not in the steps per se, but in the upper body styling or arm movements. This is where the dancer can express his or her individuality, since the steps are fixed. She also briefly describes how men's arm and handwork differs from women's.
In the second choreography, Lunaris has mini workshops on fanwork and on dancing with a partner, and runs through the entire choreography again using the fan. She uses her partner to show not only how dancers move around each other during the sevillana, but also more stylistic variations.
It should be clear by now that this DVD is a treasure, an absolute treasure. I am currently taking beginner flamenco classes and learning the sevillana as part of these. They are quite complicated, at least at first, and any online reference material has not been very good at explaining the dance part of it. To have a DVD at this price not only run down the entire choreography but also show variations is truly exquisite. The two performances at the end are an extra treat.
The bad:
As well-organized as WDNY DVDs generally are, I find myself wishing for more, especially when it comes to Lunaris' videos. The current organization allows you to watch a demonstration at full-speed with music, then have a lengthy breakdown, then have choreography and practice with music. This is great, but it bothers me that some of the basics of the dance, like how to do floreos for example, are hidden away in a long choreography, with no way to guess at where they might be. There should be an easy way to jump to the descriptions of a few basic techniques, if not have them in a different section altogether.
More specifically to this DVD, since the sevillana is such a repetitive dance, all of the instruction would make much more sense if the dance were broken down in table form and available as a screen or even for printing. It would make the choreography much easier to learn.
(These two points are the only reason I took off a star, and if I could only have taken off half, I would have!)
How to use this video:
First, watch the first choreography all the way through. Just watch it. Watch the performances to see how it all fits together. Then start doing it, but take it slowly. In a normal class, this is material covered over months -- the fact that it is all on one DVD makes this video valuable, but it is also unrealistic to expect to learn it quickly. Just focus on the feet at first, and only later practice adding the arms, and then, slowly, the hands.
That said, the sevillana is more approachable than flamenco dance. I.e., it's easier to look good dancing the sevillana. Lunaris' is a great introduction for those with no experience of it, and a wonderful reference work for those who are learning it in a live class. She has a charming on-screen persona, and she is careful to give you a sense of the culture, attitude, and context of the dance as well, so you understand the spirit as well as the movements. If you are willing to practice a little, you will not regret buying this video.
====
I became interested in Puela Lunaris's DVDs through World Dance New York, which is better known for its bellydance instructional videos. And while Lunaris has done work on the Zambra (the style of flamenco most closely associated with oriental dance) it is important to note that this video has nothing whatsoever to do with bellydance. In fact, the sevillanas are not even flamenco. They are an old, very strictly structured Spanish social dance which is sometimes performed in flamenco shows, but is also done socially in Spain. This DVD not only introduces the dance, but does an excellent job at showing how it can be performed alone, in a pair in a relaxed, social manner, and in a more showy performance style with fans.
The good:
As much as I generally do not like choreographies, this is the dance for them, since every sevillana is the same. The first choreo section is an extremely lengthy breakdown of all the movements necessary for all four sections of the sevillana dance. Lunaris is painstaking in demonstrating the steps, repeating them many times over, and then adding arms. There is instruction on posture, arm movement and placement, arm variations, the different styles of hand floreos.
Lunaris often also shows variations that can be introduced, not in the steps per se, but in the upper body styling or arm movements. This is where the dancer can express his or her individuality, since the steps are fixed. She also briefly describes how men's arm and handwork differs from women's.
In the second choreography, Lunaris has mini workshops on fanwork and on dancing with a partner, and runs through the entire choreography again using the fan. She uses her partner to show not only how dancers move around each other during the sevillana, but also more stylistic variations.
It should be clear by now that this DVD is a treasure, an absolute treasure. I am currently taking beginner flamenco classes and learning the sevillana as part of these. They are quite complicated, at least at first, and any online reference material has not been very good at explaining the dance part of it. To have a DVD at this price not only run down the entire choreography but also show variations is truly exquisite. The two performances at the end are an extra treat.
The bad:
As well-organized as WDNY DVDs generally are, I find myself wishing for more, especially when it comes to Lunaris' videos. The current organization allows you to watch a demonstration at full-speed with music, then have a lengthy breakdown, then have choreography and practice with music. This is great, but it bothers me that some of the basics of the dance, like how to do floreos for example, are hidden away in a long choreography, with no way to guess at where they might be. There should be an easy way to jump to the descriptions of a few basic techniques, if not have them in a different section altogether.
More specifically to this DVD, since the sevillana is such a repetitive dance, all of the instruction would make much more sense if the dance were broken down in table form and available as a screen or even for printing. It would make the choreography much easier to learn.
(These two points are the only reason I took off a star, and if I could only have taken off half, I would have!)
How to use this video:
First, watch the first choreography all the way through. Just watch it. Watch the performances to see how it all fits together. Then start doing it, but take it slowly. In a normal class, this is material covered over months -- the fact that it is all on one DVD makes this video valuable, but it is also unrealistic to expect to learn it quickly. Just focus on the feet at first, and only later practice adding the arms, and then, slowly, the hands.
That said, the sevillana is more approachable than flamenco dance. I.e., it's easier to look good dancing the sevillana. Lunaris' is a great introduction for those with no experience of it, and a wonderful reference work for those who are learning it in a live class. She has a charming on-screen persona, and she is careful to give you a sense of the culture, attitude, and context of the dance as well, so you understand the spirit as well as the movements. If you are willing to practice a little, you will not regret buying this video.
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Thu, December 13, 2007 - 7:18 PMHi Atisheh, thank you for the great review! I agree with your comment about having basic technique separated from the choreography and accessible directly from the menu (perhaps similar to the structure of Blanca's "Sensual Bellydance"). This is definitely the way to go when the program is very extensive and in-depth. -
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Thu, December 13, 2007 - 11:09 PMYes, precisely!
I loved the arm pose "encyclopedia" part of Sensual Bellydance. It would be amazing to have something like that for flamenco too. Lunaris really does cover a lot of that stuff during the choreos, but it would be great to have it as a reference section.
The footwork basics, that is, all the ways your foot can hit the ground, with the Spanish names as well as the English, would make another great reference section.
And, because I can dream, drills for a variety of footwork combinations, starting slowly with no arms, getting faster, and then adding arm work.
And there you have it -- a flamenco practice companion! Honestly, I'm not sure if there would be much of a market for it, but I would personally love it.
So, can I ask -- is Puela Lunaris doing any new videos for WDNY? -
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Sat, December 15, 2007 - 9:05 PMHi Atisheh, not currently, but life is long, and hey you have 3 WDNY Puela DVDs to work with! -
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Mon, December 17, 2007 - 1:52 PMAlas! But... you're right. I'm taking my sevillanas DVD with me for winter vacation, and plan to learn as much as I can. It's a good one to study a bit on my own.
Totally off-topic -- but kind of related to a previous topic -- I took an amazing workshop with Autumn Ward yesterday on "Ballet Technique for Oriental Dance". I can imagine that making a great DVD as well, especially as she broke down the differences between ballet moves as done in ballet and as done in oriental dance. -
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Tue, February 5, 2008 - 11:49 AMI know this is an old thread -- but Ballet for Bellydance is SUCH a great idea!!! Please consider exploring this in a future dvd. -
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Tue, February 5, 2008 - 4:50 PMWell, I'm always ready to jump on an old thread... especially when I started it!
This kind of continues some of the themes we've been talking about on bellydancevideos, but I think it fits here too. I really think using the potential of DVDs to organize things in different ways adds immensely to the value of instructionals. Neon, I don't know if you follow the yahoogroup, but I'm going to give you props here as well for doing such creative work with the DVD format.
Maybe it's just the way I think, but I like encyclopedias. I like reference works. I like being reminded of different possibilities. That's why I loved that arm posture reference. And while there are a bunch of ballet workouts on the market already (and I'm really not sure we need another one), I think a ballet reference for non-ballet dancers would be great. For Bellydance, even better. Imagine being able to look up a word you hear in class, find out what it means to a ballet dancer, and then see what it might mean in a bellydance context! -
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Thu, February 7, 2008 - 9:35 PMHi Aziyade and Atisheh, thank you for your suggestions - will keep in mind! I did read the other day the Yahoo group's posts you mentioned - very instructive, interesting discussion.
Atisheh, like you, I am a systematic learner and thinker - I totally relate to what you say about encyclopaedia-style format. My first video work, Instant Bellydancer, was designed as a systematic learning tool, to which I attribute its lasting success: It offered streamlined systematic learning for beginners at the time when the predominant format for the videos was oriented toward more empirical learning, the choices offered to students were governed by aesthetics and the scope of material the instructor wished to offer, rather than a systematic structure.
As I kept working on video programs I realized that a more intuitive, less systematic approach is also extremely valid if served right - a lot of our programs are very organic, they grow like plants from a one cell organism to a blooming tree - I find it very interesting that so many of our instructors turned this approach into very successful teaching methods. -
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Fri, February 8, 2008 - 7:14 AMYeah, I think we've discussed this on PM -- it's the linguistic mindset!
Actually, I have to agree with you about the intuitive approach. I also prefer that sometimes. And I have to admit that some things just can't be taught very well in a list. I was delighted to get the Jenna DVD in the mail recently, but on a first look I was surprised to find no "transitions" sections. I read the copy and thought, "Duh, of course, how *would* you teach transitions except by doing a choreo? There have to be movements between the transitions!"
I imagine that everybody has a particular preference, and that for most people the sweet spot lies in a combination of the two methods. And this really is *exactly* like language learning! Some people prefer a grammar, some people prefer conversation, but most really need a bit of both if they want to speak and to read.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: DVD review: Flamenco You Can Do It! Sevillanas, by Puela Lunaris
Thu, March 6, 2008 - 6:45 PM"I became interested in Puela Lunaris's DVDs through World Dance New York, which is better known for its bellydance instructional videos. And while Lunaris has done work on the Zambra"
Ah-ha, was looking for Zambra and came across this thread. Forgive my lateness. Saw the mention of Lunaris doing work on Zambra, is this something she teaches or has taught live or are there DVDs out there with Zambra on them?
Thanks!
~Z.