Advertisement
Peter:
"But know that, even on an island, you /will/ have a relationship with local folks, and unless you integrate them tightly into your project from before day 1 (and probably even then), rumours will develop about the crazy hippies having free love parties on the island out there. Ask Bruno at El Zopilote in Madroñal, on Maderas, about that."
"People will not understand what you are doing, and they will invent stories. Their opinion of you will be based in no small part on what they feel you've done for them and for their community, and the rapore you've developed with them. Given that you're talking about buying a large island off Granada, "they" refers to the people of Granada in general (Nicas and foreigners) as well as the whole South-West quadrant of Nicaragua to a lesser extent. You will struggle with this, and there is no easy solution. "
The island is much closer to Chontales than Granada, but I think Peter makes a very valid point.
Once the project is underway, I'm pondering the idea of having "open houses" every couple of months where we invite the local community to come out and see the island and what we're doing. (It's a day where we should probably dress up.) This would be a start at least.
Maybe like good neighbors, we could even provide some transport from Puerto Diez and have a BBQ. Is there better way is there to befriend and get to know your neighbors than having a BBQ?
As for doing good in the country, I think the best possible scenario would be us simply leading by example. If we come up with great new ways to adapt local construction techniques, or to cheaply provide sustainable energy, then let's just build it for ourselves. In these "open houses", we could let the locals can come out and see how we're living. Then if any of them are interested in doing these things for themselves, we could help them.
This is pretty different from anything that we've proposed before. What do people think?
"But know that, even on an island, you /will/ have a relationship with local folks, and unless you integrate them tightly into your project from before day 1 (and probably even then), rumours will develop about the crazy hippies having free love parties on the island out there. Ask Bruno at El Zopilote in Madroñal, on Maderas, about that."
"People will not understand what you are doing, and they will invent stories. Their opinion of you will be based in no small part on what they feel you've done for them and for their community, and the rapore you've developed with them. Given that you're talking about buying a large island off Granada, "they" refers to the people of Granada in general (Nicas and foreigners) as well as the whole South-West quadrant of Nicaragua to a lesser extent. You will struggle with this, and there is no easy solution. "
The island is much closer to Chontales than Granada, but I think Peter makes a very valid point.
Once the project is underway, I'm pondering the idea of having "open houses" every couple of months where we invite the local community to come out and see the island and what we're doing. (It's a day where we should probably dress up.) This would be a start at least.
Maybe like good neighbors, we could even provide some transport from Puerto Diez and have a BBQ. Is there better way is there to befriend and get to know your neighbors than having a BBQ?
As for doing good in the country, I think the best possible scenario would be us simply leading by example. If we come up with great new ways to adapt local construction techniques, or to cheaply provide sustainable energy, then let's just build it for ourselves. In these "open houses", we could let the locals can come out and see how we're living. Then if any of them are interested in doing these things for themselves, we could help them.
This is pretty different from anything that we've proposed before. What do people think?
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Thu, February 14, 2008 - 4:36 PMi think (leading by example, rather than any of the other possibilities) youve got a great idea there. now, to be truthful, i dont know if culturally itd work the way youre proposing here - but from where i sit here in the usa, it seems like a great way to do things.
i think the acid test is to get some vocal nicaraguans in here (even here-here, in this thread/tribe) to help us determine whether what we say/do is going to be received the way we mean/want it to be received. i agree with your ideas and understand the perspective that you are coming from - i just wonder what a real granada-resident would think. -
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Sun, March 30, 2008 - 7:50 AM"i think (leading by example, rather than any of the other possibilities) youve got a great idea there. now, to be truthful, i dont know if culturally itd work the way youre proposing here - but from where i sit here in the usa, it seems like a great way to do things."
How very dominate cultural this reads. America first. In someone else's country.
Fuckin hilarious in a burner driven creation. -
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Sun, March 30, 2008 - 7:51 AMNot your statement fyi - the "lead by example" earlier.
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Mon, March 31, 2008 - 12:51 AMi dont think anyone wants to push 'america first' for anything. id think we were trying to bring burner culture along with us, but thats a far cry from 'american'. hell, i dont even think most people that would get involved would readily identify themselves as american, considering anyone who gets involved will pretty much be planning on leaving the states for at least a good portion of the year, if not more.
for that matter, most of us embrace burner culture because it is an escape from american culture. or at least i do. im certainly not trying to build a little america in nicaragua. though i think i will appreciate english being the dominant language in the project.
and i think leading by example is a very burner thing to do... isnt that what weve been doing for 20 years now? granted, 'leading' might be a poorly chosen word, but 'demonstrating an alternative method, by example' seems a bit unwieldly. :)
i wouldnt even want to push anything on anyone, local or not. from a cultural standpoint we americans really arent even in a position to go around telling people how to do things 'better', IMHO. but some of our skills as burners might just be useful to some people. if we can help, cool; if not, thats cool too. but before we could even offer anything, we would have to be able to point to having done it before, on our island. -
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Mon, March 31, 2008 - 9:03 AMTia's criticisms seemed to be fueled by alcohol and posted merely to inflame.
Creating a small society on an isolated island is not an attempt to colonialize...............I would imagine that a fair amount of local peoples and business would benefit from the presence. Whither thru business relationships or personal. -
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Mon, March 31, 2008 - 9:35 PMGlen, I hope that Tia was just giving honest constructive criticism.
And Trae is right, "leading" wasn't quite the right word.
But I think that Tia must have misread something if she was so upset by the idea.
Tia, let me try to explain again what was meant.
Most NGOs do things on behalf the local people, potentially building a culture of dependence, or they assume that they know what is right and arrogantly try to teach the locals how to do things.
I was talking about a model where we do our best to learn about local techniques for construction and farming, and then try to improve upon that with what we as a group know about technology, permaculture, etc. We build these things for ourselves - that's the "leading by example" part of it.
But then, through open houses, or other means, we show what we're doing. If the locals are interested in some of it, then we share it with them, and help them to do it for themselves. That's the thought. -
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Tue, April 1, 2008 - 5:15 PMAdam, I wasn't "so upset". I understand where you are coming from with the show the way however find the "lead by example" to be quite arrogant when in another country.
-
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Tue, April 1, 2008 - 5:13 PMGlen, I wasn't drinking and find your statements to be the usual inflammatory ones.
My criticisms are well-founded and designed to bring a different perspective than the one you happen to have.
-
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Fri, April 25, 2008 - 9:16 AMPsssst!!!! Nicaraguans ARE Americans....
-
-
-
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Fri, February 15, 2008 - 11:51 AMactually i suggested something similar (or meant to maybe? it was awhile ago) to go along with the 'full moon parties' / seasonal parties. 4 weekends a year where we just open the doors, and maybe one more day as a freebie to anyone that wants to help clean up. i think we will do better to LEAVE the island and be involved though. go to the market in granada and demonstrate our methods of cheap energy or whatnot. use the island as our lab, and the mainland as our showroom. go out BWB style and build houses from the techniques weve learned. BM give free tickets to gerlach locals... but as FM is a bit different i can see us getting taken advantage of more (like if BM were right outside san fran, and gave free passes to the locals... just wouldnt work). either way i think it might be better to be seen 'out' doing things, as a group, before we publically say something akin to 'hey, dude, come check out my house!'
talking about freebies and open houses is a bit premature until we know we can pay for the land itself. totally agree we should work towards something like this, but maybe not -plan- for it until we know more how everything will work. or maybe a free weekend would get more attention to the project? "come party with us, then tomorrow we work on your house" also, 4 times a year might be too often.
also, while i do want to see us involved with the locals, the island is in nicaragua and that should not be denied, i see our project as a GLOBAL thing (that adam has been talking about it all over the place is great :) ). BM is international, and FM is the next step, and the first step of its kind in the world. -
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Fri, February 15, 2008 - 3:34 PMTrae:
> think we will do better to LEAVE the island and be involved though.
I see room for both things. I think it would be the wrong thing to do, and contrary to our other goals, to buy a piece of Nicaraguan Land and then exclude the Nicas from it. Having open houses now and then would help solve that.
> talking about freebies and open houses is a bit premature until we know we can pay for the land itself.
Yes and no. One concern that I'm hearing from other travelers is that we're going to create an all-white zone in a latin country. I don't know if we'll be giving anything away for free until the project is financially self-sufficient, but it would be good to show that we are thinking about these things.
Though, we might want to start the open houses ASAP actually. They don't necessary need to cost us anything.
> i see our project as a GLOBAL thing
Side note. Met some people big into the global festival scene. They are English and Irish, and are actually part-owners in a guesthouse and festival zone in China.
www.dragonflydali.com/
They said that they'd spread the word for us.
harold:
> i think the acid test is to get some vocal nicaraguans in here (even here-here, in this thread/tribe) to help us determine whether what we say/do is going to be received the way we mean/want it to be received.
Hmmmm. Most Nicaraguans speak no English. The views of the minority who do speak English, probably don't reflect the majority.
But it would be interesting if we could find a Nica-American who wants to share their thoughts.
> i just wonder what a real granada-resident would think.
I'll just share my experiences in Mustang Saloon. I told them what we're trying to do. My Spanish isn't good enough to get into a real subtle conversation, but I can speak of their reaction. They told me that they know about the island. The next day, they rounded up some other friends who had even more information about the island - and I got the name of the lawyer for the owner, among other things. The people of Juigalpa, or at least Mustang Saloon, are helping me find the information that I need. So, it seems that they definitely aren't opposed to the idea.
(note - unlike 'Pakis', 'Nicas' is not an negative slur. The Nicaraguans, Nicas, tend to abbreviate much of their language, including what they call themselves.)
-
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Wed, February 27, 2008 - 1:07 AMHmm. No, I don't think it's enough. People will not "get it". They will not observe what you've set up and try to mimic it. They don't have the money for solar panels anyway. People are hard to change, and Nicaraguans are no exception. I'm not sure technology is really the level that matters anyway, except perhaps for some agricultural technology.
There have been several projects on Ometepe trying to get people to use solar ovens, or at least don't kill the women standing over them so many hours a day. They have all experienced very limited success. It boggles the mind at times, when the benefits of a different way are so clear, but so it is. Transfer of technology and technique are not the right places to start forming relationships.
I'd like to echo the concern you're hearing about about making a white island. It's weird. No amount of BBQs and open houses will change that. It's weird. I, for one, would not be interested in such an insular community, but I would be interested in an integrated community, even if the locals were paid for their involvement.
I think one of your major goals, whether you've said it or not, is to challenge yourselves, to be changed at a fundamental level. This means subjecting yourselves to the Other. Nicaraguans have a huge amount to teach all of us about being locally- and self-reliant. Their approaches to problem solving, for example, sometimes seem backwards at first, but also serve to challenge the assumptions underlying our own approaches. They're also wonderful people.
So--let them help you build what you want to build. Find good people. Make friends with them. They might learn something about how you work along the way, especially younger people, but that's not the point. You've already experienced their good-natured and friendly helpfulness. They probably still won't understand what you're really trying to do, or why, but maybe you won't understand those things for a long time, either.
Still, if you were to spark in even some even small way hope, vision, and goals in people for whom those things have only brought suffering, and show them that one can work towards them through diligence and hard work, that would be a profoundly good deed. I'm not sure at this stage what someone might see in your project, but I think there will be opportunities to do this.
As for full moon parties and what I said before about public perception, I really do mean that you should talk to Bruno if you at all have the chance. Michael Judd should still be in Balgüe, Altagracia, as well.
None of this should be taken to mean that I have anything against parties. Parties are awesome. -
-
Re: Opening the project up to the Nicaraguans
Wed, February 27, 2008 - 5:54 PMPeter:
> They don't have the money for solar panels anyway.
The world seems to be changing. They are out of the price range of most Nicaraguans. But I ran into a solar shop in the tiny town of San Carlos. It's a chain called "tecnosol" and has stores all around Nicaragua.
> It boggles the mind at times, when the benefits of a different way are so clear, but so it is. Transfer of technology and technique are not the right places to start forming relationships.
This is getting pretty far off topic. But this lecture from a MIT professor talks a bit near the end of the lecture about setting up tech labs in developing countries. It's interesting stuff.
www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/90
> I'd like to echo the concern you're hearing about about making a white island. It's weird. No amount of BBQs and open houses will change that. It's weird. I, for one, would not be interested in such an insular community, but I would be interested in an integrated community, even if the locals were paid for their involvement.
Interesting comments. And things to think about.
But I think that the project could still be great, even if there weren't Nicaraguans involved. Look at early Burningman with no Nevadans in attendance. Only later did people start driving up from Reno, and some of them now really add to the event.
> I think one of your major goals, whether you've said it or not, is to challenge yourselves, to be changed at a fundamental level. This means subjecting yourselves to the Other. Nicaraguans have a huge amount to teach all of us about being locally- and self-reliant.
Another interesting point. But I don't think that this really has to be a goal for people. Or even, I think that trying too hard to be like the locals might come across as condescending.
I've spent a long time in developing countries, and think this change is just a natural thing. You spend enough time in Nicaragua, and you'll learn things, and find yourself a different, and hopefully better person in the end.
> As for full moon parties and what I said before about public perception, I really do mean that you should talk to Bruno if you at all have the chance. Michael Judd should still be in Balgüe, Altagracia, as well.
I've written a little bit about this, but Juigalpa came as a huge surprise for me. Juigalpa is a small Catholic cowboy town. But there is a big gay scene including some transvestites, which I was really surprised to see. And there's at least one good nightclub with young people dancing into the night. Or at least on Valentines Day it was very hot and steamy.
I'm sure you're right that there are going to be some cultural problems and rumors going around about us. But I'm happy to see that at least in Chontales, there is a bit of tolerance towards such things.
Cheers!
-
