Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 8:42 AMthe long and the short of it:
the long answer is gone over in multiple posts on previous pages. please do read them. a lot of important information is in older posts.
the short answer is that it simply seems to work out best for our situation. islands of a minimum price and maximum size arent exactly common :) -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 10:43 AMI knew that I posted the long answer to that question recently. Here's it is again:
Three of our goals in starting this project were:
* to find a place on the water
* to find a place which inspires the imagination
* and to find a place where we can be relatively speaking free of rules and regulations
I think that we can achieve those goals in Nicaragua, but not in America.
Finding an affordable place in America, on the water, which inspires the imagination is a difficult thing indeed. There are islands for sale in Cananda and Maine, but they are freezing cold for most of the year. Someone recently posted about a plot of land in Hawaii, but it was 6 times the price of our Island. Other groups have had ideas to to set up communities in America, but largely they've been on rather dull plots of land - certainly nothing as exciting as a private island.
There are cheap islands for sale in the Philipines, but that's way too far away. There are reasonably priced islands for sale in other countries in Central America, but the visa restrictions are more difficult. Nicaragua is the only country in Central America where you can endlessly renew your visa to stay in the country, and easy get a permanent residency visa if you wish.
Also, if we're in America, we will have to deal with all of the stringent legal codes and building permits. You now need health permits to serve food at Burningman. We want to avoid that sort of thing for our project. To make a wild guess (I haven't been in Nicaragua since 1999), I'd say that the legal codes in Nicaragua are probably about 30 years behind America. Remember back in the 70s when you could drive down the street with a beer in hand? That's where I'm guessing Nicaragua is today. I will be back down in Nicaragua soon, and I will report back with more details.
(Since it keeps coming up, I guess I need to add this info to the FAQ.) -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 11:37 AMThat I understand, I suppose my real question should've been: After the island is purchased, can we form a country, or will the island have to stay part of Nicaragua? -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 1:39 PM> After the island is purchased, can we form a country, or will the island have to stay part of Nicaragua?
No. We will still be subject to the laws of Nicaragua.
Though, simply due to the physical distance we will have a limited degree of autonomy. It's just like living way out in the countryside - if the cops don't know what you're up to, there isn't much they're going to do about it.
Creating our own country was a dream that we had at the beginning of this project - scroll back to the original posts from 2 years ago. But to do so, we'd basically have to build our own island in international waters. A very dangerous undertaking, to say the least. We're not ready to do that. We should start with the relatively safe undertaking of building floating art from an island. From there, we can work our way up to bigger, crazier things. -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 3:50 PMFair enough, but there's only 242 people on this tribe. How realistic is it and what sort of time frame do you have? Because if it can happen in the next couple of years, I'll gladly send you a hundo. But if, you're thinking like 5+ years....well i don't know. -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 4:26 PMDemographically speaking, 242 on this website is not a discouraging number. Creating more than one communication network is a next step.
About forming your own country: you absolutely must have either WMD or a powerful 'conventional' force for killing. That's the world we're living in. WMD are *the* essential tools of statecraft for small countries. -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 4:33 PM"About forming your own country: you absolutely must have either WMD or a powerful 'conventional' force for killing. That's the world we're living in. WMD are *the* essential tools of statecraft for small countries."
Or at least an alliance w/ a country that has those essential tools. -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 4:55 PMWithout the weapons to protect us from the allies, we finlandize immediately into their country. Or, so history suggests.
Maybe there's an ethical / moral nation out there to ally with.....
}:) Lokifreign: quality poopin' on the statehood party since '96 -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 10:11 PM"Maybe there's an ethical / moral nation out there to ally with....."
I hear Jasonia is kind of a libertarian free for all.
-
-
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, September 27, 2007 - 4:54 PMLoki:
> About forming your own country: you absolutely must have either WMD or a powerful 'conventional' force for killing. That's the world we're living in.
Or a very good publicist. :-)
jason:
> How realistic is it and what sort of time frame do you have?
We've already been discussing and brainstorming for two years. And now, we have an idea that at least Trae and I are pretty happy with. If you have any questions about our plan or vision, either of us will be happy to answer them.
isee is now working with us to refine the financially projections, and step by step that is making rapid forward progress.
Spread the word, because as soon as we have 50 people who have sent in an application and a deposit, I'll be ready to go to Nicaragua and hire a lawyer to research the property title and make sure that everything is okay with that.
And if the property title is okay, when we reach 100 people we'll be ready to go and purchase the island and move in.
(One small note - when I'm in Nicaragua I'll also be looking at other pieces of property - maybe land on Ometepe - but that shouldn't heavily effect the timeline.)
We're only at 3 people right now. But A'lan promised to sign up, so that's 46 left. If you sign up, then we only need 45 more.
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Fri, September 28, 2007 - 12:03 PM>About forming your own country: you absolutely must have either WMD or a powerful 'conventional' force for killing. That's the world we're living in. WMD are *the* essential tools of statecraft for small countries.
i would slightly disagree there. i see where your coming from, and conventionally i would agree. but if we made a country of a floating derelict boat? a flotilla of rafts and fishing skiffs? an island of soda bottles? there would be no reason for anyone to take this over, we wouldnt have anything worth taking. and as we wouldnt necessarily create our own country so much as simply leave one (this IS a bunch anarchists on here, remember? :) ), most of us would still officially retain american citizenship. so if anyone did attack us it would be an attack on a significant number of americans... which i dont think many countries want to do.
its all about looking at it sideways if we really want to make something new.
-
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Fri, September 28, 2007 - 11:53 AM>Fair enough, but there's only 242 people on this tribe. How realistic is it and what sort of time frame do you have? Because if it can happen in the next couple of years, I'll gladly send you a hundo. But if, you're thinking like 5+ years....well i don't know.
its as realistic as we can come up with. if anyone can find errors in our ideas they are encouraged to show us, but so far it seems completely doable. there is some risk involved, but what that is worthwhile is risk-free? the more people that decide to try with us, the closer we get to making it happen. i think there will be a certain landslide effect, where as soon as we get the first people, when people start taking the project seriously, the rest will come in a wave.
so its hard to judge the timeframe. i see no reason why it couldnt happen within the next year, and thats what i would like to see (and definitely before 5 years!). but it takes people taking the first step. if someone did have to back out, after sending money, they would get their money back (except what of the $100 was needed for expenses to that point). -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 2, 2007 - 11:15 PMall right. so this is exactly what i was thinking about tonight. i am guessing here, but it could be that for some people, this thing is kinda far fetched at this point. one obvious thing that comes to mind is that you have been at it for two years ( i think) and you have a hand full of people on board and a whole bunch of people just waiting or lurking or whatever. how is this gonna happen in 2 years from now or 3 or 5? where is that threshold we are looking for? that turning point, where people start believing this is gonna happen and so they easily join? i bet many many people can afford this thing the way it is. but how do you make that jump?
so, my question is kinda fundamental? can you apply other measures like other financial models or even marketing models to this thing? the idea is marketable, and by that i mean you can talk about it and get people excited but how far will you go?
is the model you have chosen concrete? 100 people at 3,000 a pop? what if i said we can get fewer people with more money in? and if you can't afford the buy in, you do something to pay yourself in? or whatever? is that the same thing as the relation of labor and capital and is that not self reliant?
different kind of financing or / marketing models -- what if we got a few rich people to sponsor it and then let them earn a lifetime membership as a guest? just saying, what if?
i know there are some guiding principles, but should we explore the edges? i am not sure where the boundaries of self reliance are.
not sure what but there is something here that needs to be discussed. i think. i maybe saying blasphemous stuff, but i think maybe there is some creative way we could market or package this that could get us there faster. is this what is killing burning man? this kind of thought process? applying normal/real life models to the idea?
i am just thinking out loud. -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 2, 2007 - 11:56 PMPersonally, I think one of the things that is "killing" burningman is a division of the community into the empowered, and the disenfranchised.
There is no blasphemy in Floatingman -- except possibly a wish to make a profit off of the project.
If you have an idea completely contrary to what we're planning or doing, let us know. It's quite possible that your idea is better than ours. :-)
But we have a plan which we think is pretty good, and we're moving forward with it.
> can you apply other measures like other financial models or even marketing models to this thing? the idea is marketable, and by that i mean you can talk about it and get people excited but how far will you go?
Give us ideas. What do you think will work?
> is the model you have chosen concrete? 100 people at 3,000 a pop? what if i said we can get fewer people with more money in? and if you can't afford the buy in, you do something to pay yourself in?
The model is not concrete. If a better idea comes up, I think that we would be willing to change it.
But we chose an amount which was intentionally low in order to allow as many people as possible to afford a share.
And we decided that we would not allow people to provide labor to cover part of their share. _Everyone_ is supposed to be contributing to making this happen. Why would we give one person a discounted price in exchange for labor, but not everyone else? I think that we're all in this together, and we all need to pay an equal share.
> what if we got a few rich people to sponsor it and then let them earn a lifetime membership as a guest? just saying, what if?
Well.... if they're accepted as an owner, for only $3000 they'll have a lifetime membership with rights to come to the island whenever they wish anyways.
Personally, I'd be very happy if a wealthy burner decided that they wanted to support the project with either a large donation or a large loan. However, when we discussed this previously, and decided that large contributors would have no more say in the running of the project than any other owners. Their extra contribution would have to be solely because they wanted to make this happen.
Is this a path we should start pursuing more heavily?
> where is that threshold we are looking for? that turning point, where people start believing this is gonna happen and so they easily join?
Here are my personal thresholds: When we reach 50 applicants, I'm hiring a Nicaraguan lawyer to research the title. When we're over 100 applicants, hopefully more, we'll be ready to buy.
There is also talk of holding a small regional burn on the island this winter. It would be something of a try-before-you-buy event. We could rent out the island and see if we like it. I'm not sure if this will just be a lot of work for not much progress, or if this will be a good way to get people inspired, in addition to allowing more people to check out the property before we buy it.
We're only officially 3 right now. But Wisecat sent in his check, and the letter somehow didn't make it to Trae's new address, and was returned to him. I just sent a message to him asking him to resend it. A'lan has said that he'd sign up - I'll call him tomorrow. Someone mailed me on tribe and told me that he loved the idea and was ready to sign up, and that he had some friends who might also want to sign up. I'm meeting with Organizizer on Thursday, and I'll try to convince him that we're not going to be evil and that he wants to join us. So... we could potentially be at 6 or 8 one week from now.
> how do you make that jump?
How do you make that jump indeed?
How do we find 95 more people passionate and crazy enough to build something amazing and new? -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 9:02 AM"I think that we're all in this together, and we all need to pay an equal share. "
Because specialized skills are sometimes more valuable than dollar signs.
Because a community built with equality of membership/ownership does not necessarily need to include equal financial contribution to be equal contribution.
Just a thought.
Last one is that 3000 for some community members would be much, much more difficult than others to come up with in a realistic sense where larger contributions would be just as easy and just as reasonable. -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 1:13 PMTia:
> Have you or adam contacted attorneys in Nica to see about what the "could go wrongs" are.
No. I think that the best approach would be to talk to local expat business people after I get down there. They are probably in the best position to know what we might experience, and also the most likely to be honest with us.
> How far from the mainland is this?
Actually, it's about 6 miles off the NE corner of Lake Nicaragua - a freshwater lake the size of a small sea.
> It appears most involved in the project are U.S. citizens or Canadian citizens - what is the current relationship with embassies in the area? Have they been contacted?
It's been my impression that the US embassy is totally useless in giving information to travelers. The state department does publish the country list - but they tend to grossly exaggerate any possibility of danger.
> Drug laws (yes some burners who may be interested in this do not want to give up their ganga), patterns of locking up without contact or charge are not at all unheard of in Nicaragua going back at least 30 years that I'm aware of.
We should look for more info on this.
But, I'm under the impression that Nicaragua is changing fast. And it's a very different place than it was 10 or even 5 years ago. I spoke to someone yesterday who warned me "It's filling up with Americans". It's also filling up with retirees.
"The world’s best-kept retirement secret"
"Nicaragua is virtually unknown to most people and usually misunderstood, which is why forward-thinking investors can find some of the best real-estate deals on Earth in this country."
"Safe and stunning"
articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Ret...aspx
"Advantages Outweigh Problems -- While the bureaucracy is sometimes maddening, say the residents, the advantages still outway the problems."
www.transitionsabroad.com/publi....shtml
Do we need to do more research on this now, or can it wait until people head down there?
> I think that we're all in this together, and we all need to pay an equal share. ... Just a thought.
I don't know if any proposal is ever perfect.
Do you see a model of "pay what you're able" working? I think that the best compromise is the same fee for everyone, plus an expectation that people will contribute some degree of work towards making the project a success.
If you have a different model which you think will work better, let us know.
> Was Mexico considered?
We were looking for an island. And there were no islands for sale in Mexico. Panama was considered and rejected because stricter immigration laws made it impossible for most of our owners to live there. Belize was considered and rejected because the prices, per acre, were much more expensive.
> An attorney, a title search (know how to do it here...not there tho), and other things should be clear before even bothering checking with realtors.
We've collecting partially refundable $100 application fees right now. These funds will be used to pay for a top-Nicaraguan lawyer to do that title search. As I see it, it's one of our absolutely highest priorities. But we need more people to apply to be an owner before we have the cash to do the title search. -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 9:05 PM"We've collecting partially refundable $100 application fees right now. These funds will be used to pay for a top-Nicaraguan lawyer to do that title search. As I see it, it's one of our absolutely highest priorities. But we need more people to apply to be an owner before we have the cash to do the title search."
Ok. So what is needed to pay for this "top" Nicaraguan lawyer to do the title search? -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 10:01 PMTia:
> Ok. So what is needed to pay for this "top" Nicaraguan lawyer to do the title search?
We only have a very vague guess: less than $5000.
But also having 50 applicants (1/2 the number of final owners) seemed like an appropriate point to start checking the property title.
> I think it's a good idea to mention them again.
Agreed.
If there are any unanswered questions, please let us know, and Trae or I should be able to answer them. :-)
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 8:58 AMI'd have signed up but have concerns about the particular country chosen.
Was Mexico considered?
I have a friend, who I attended law school with here in the states, who wrote a very helpful guideline for purchasing large property in that country. It is a more predictable country imho. Isee is correct that for some people this seems to be an interested dream but "far fetched".
An attorney, a title search (know how to do it here...not there tho), and other things should be clear before even bothering checking with realtors. Do we even know if the realtor himself is able to sell this particular property or could he be a full of shit person ready to swallow whatever funds are gathered for said purchase?
-
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 11:09 AMevery island we could find was considered. theres a HUGE one in south america, talking 6000+ acres... but its only an island on a river. there were a couple thoughts of islands in the philippians's, but those were shot down for various reasons. there was a rather long and complicated debate about the nica island vs the belize island. it was never about the country first, simply the land available.
i dont think anything about the project is actually set in stone. if you, or anyone, can come up with a better idea, share it and it just might be the new 'plan'. hell, this wasnt even about an island in the beginning.
may i ask what your particular concerns are about nica? i had a few myself, but am am pretty much relieved of them now.
at the moment, funds are being collected for things such as the title search and attorney fees. we are not collecting the full amounts yet. if, when these things are done, we find that this guy actually cannot sell this property to us, we dont go any further with it. of course. but until we find a better idea, or find that this one is not possible, we go forward as much as we can. if it turns out this island will not work for us, we would go back to the drawing board, and make a new plan (which might be cheaper/more expensive, or whatever, at least there would be more people involved that time).
you can check all the discussions on these issues in previous threads. again, if youve got a better idea, the rest of us want to hear it :) -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 9:04 PM
you can check all the discussions on these issues in previous threads. again, if youve got a better idea, the rest of us want to hear it :)
See I have checked out the other threads...and they are basically you and adam talking with a few other folks involved. I haven't seen the actual answers. I have responded regarding concerns in the other thread though.
I think it's a good idea to mention them again.
Kinda like mentioning the Borg and transparency/hypocrisy in multiple threads.....;-) -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Tue, October 23, 2007 - 9:25 PM>I think it's a good idea to mention them again.
agreed. i keep hoping to keep this somewhat organized, so we can find particular continuing discussions for future reference, though i know that isnt really realistic. its already confusing enough. i should work on getting everything organized more accessibly.
it is a lot of adam and i talking. id really like it to be less of that honestly. ill dig around for more specific answers, if they are already somewhere (some decisions were finalized in those monthly meetings, and so might not be on tribe).
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Sat, March 28, 2009 - 4:01 PM
Here is quite a bit of research (yes, paid for mostly by taxes) on all of the Central American countries... and Nicaragua isn't on the top of the good-list btw.
Mexico.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/mx.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/mx.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
El Salvador.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/sv.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/es.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
Honduras.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/hn.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/ho.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
Nicaragua.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/ni.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/nu.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
Costa Rica.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/cr.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/cs.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
Panama.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/pa.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/pm.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
Belize.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/bz.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/bh.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
Guatemala.
* www.worldatlas.com/webimage...ca/gt.htm
* www.cia.gov/library/publ.../geos/gt.html
* www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreEconomies/
-
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Sat, March 28, 2009 - 7:43 PMHow's about Fiji? LOTS of island there... -
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Sun, March 29, 2009 - 8:18 PMJahvan:
Fiji is gorgeous. It's also very, vary far away from almost everything, and pretty darn expensive.
So, it's probably a poor choice for us. -
-
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, April 2, 2009 - 12:47 PMsome are working farms .. coffe ... mango .... not sure about lot sizes in all cases:
www.encuentra24.com/clasific...1-en.html
www.encuentra24.com/clasific...1-en.html
www.encuentra24.com/clasific...1-en.html
www.mondinion.com/Real_Esta...velopment/
www.encuentra24.com/clasific...1-en.html
www.encuentra24.com/clasific...1-en.html
-
Re: Why Nicaragua?
Thu, April 2, 2009 - 12:55 PMIndigo:
Ometepe is like the Garden of Eden. It's an amazing place. It could be an excellent choice
But boarhead got me thinking again. There are some great things about Nicaragua. But our strongest reason for picking it was that it had the best choice in private islands.
If we're looking for beachfront property, I'm now thinking more about Baja. How much more viable would this project be if Americans could easily drive down to it?
-
-