So I apologize for probably not learning enough about your project before posting, or distinguishing clearly between posts from people who are committed to the project and newcomers like me.
Let me start by saying that a bunch of capable, idealistic people who put their heads together and committed to Nicaragua could be a boon to the country and its people, who could use an infusion of hope. Should this project be committed to local people to the degree that Burners Without Borders is, with a committed base of people, even a small group, it would make a real difference in peoples' lives. Living on an island seems in conflict with that vision, but I'm willing to give y'all the benefit of the doubt.
In fact I wasn't able to find a vision statement on your website or the wiki--if there is one, please direct me to it. If there is not, it seems like you are jumping the gun considerably in addressing most practical concerns.
I must also make a plea that people stop butchering the names of local landmarks. They're spelled "Ometepe" (three e's), "Maderas," "Concepción," and "Mombacho." It made me extremely uncomfortable to hear people talking about the possibility of buying an island in a land they have not spent enough time in to know how the names of the places.
I guess my point is that this effort really needs to grow out of a significant understanding of and appreciation for the specific context you want to work with, on the one hand, and a well-articulated vision of what you're trying to achieve on the other. I'm not seeing that. The two of course develop to some extent together. I would expect the process leading up to commitment (actual purchase of land, e.g.) to take at least 2-3 years.
If there remain serious concerns about Mombacho or Concepción erupting, I can probably dredge up contact information for a gentleman at INETER, the Nicaraguan governmental body that (among other things) monitors volcanos and assesses the risks posed by them.
I'm happy to continue this conversation, but feel like I should stop here before I ride too far on my initial assumptions.
Good luck and take care,
Peter Abrahamsen
Let me start by saying that a bunch of capable, idealistic people who put their heads together and committed to Nicaragua could be a boon to the country and its people, who could use an infusion of hope. Should this project be committed to local people to the degree that Burners Without Borders is, with a committed base of people, even a small group, it would make a real difference in peoples' lives. Living on an island seems in conflict with that vision, but I'm willing to give y'all the benefit of the doubt.
In fact I wasn't able to find a vision statement on your website or the wiki--if there is one, please direct me to it. If there is not, it seems like you are jumping the gun considerably in addressing most practical concerns.
I must also make a plea that people stop butchering the names of local landmarks. They're spelled "Ometepe" (three e's), "Maderas," "Concepción," and "Mombacho." It made me extremely uncomfortable to hear people talking about the possibility of buying an island in a land they have not spent enough time in to know how the names of the places.
I guess my point is that this effort really needs to grow out of a significant understanding of and appreciation for the specific context you want to work with, on the one hand, and a well-articulated vision of what you're trying to achieve on the other. I'm not seeing that. The two of course develop to some extent together. I would expect the process leading up to commitment (actual purchase of land, e.g.) to take at least 2-3 years.
If there remain serious concerns about Mombacho or Concepción erupting, I can probably dredge up contact information for a gentleman at INETER, the Nicaraguan governmental body that (among other things) monitors volcanos and assesses the risks posed by them.
I'm happy to continue this conversation, but feel like I should stop here before I ride too far on my initial assumptions.
Good luck and take care,
Peter Abrahamsen
-
Re: On local geography
Thu, February 7, 2008 - 4:23 PMhowdee peter! welcome to the fm-tribe.
im not the one to answer your questions or to try to adjust your assumptions. all i can really do is to say - thank you for correcting us about the spellings and the offer to involve more knowledgable folks re the volcanos.
i havent been over to the wiki in a few days, but if you are interested - feel free to start a page there which helps on spellings and pronunciations or whatever else strikes your fancy. actually, even a mini-tutorial on how to get the simple accent over the letters correctly would be useful. i can never remember how to do that simple task atm. :)
a vision statement would indeed be useful. i was under the impression that there was effectively a vision statement, but that it was a bit more self-centered than you were describing. i will make a possibly-apt (tho this is only MY opinion) analogy. in the usa, when we were expanding across the continent - we went into the relative unknown, encountering natives, and with totally selfish reasons and different cultures. one could argue that this was a "bad" thing. i dont want to debate that, personally. MY understanding of this project is that it is similar, a group of folks who want to go to a new territory and setup their own vision of a society. in that sense, it could be argued that buying an unoccupied island is about the most benign way that this influx of people/culture/whatever can arrive to the native area.
again, one could argue that this is a "bad" thing. i will leave that debate to you and others who have a firmer grasp of the process and motivations of fm.
mainly, i just wanted to welcome you. i have volunteered to be a greeter. i have not even sent in my $100, altho i must admit im almost interested enough to try it - so i cannot speak as a true member. if you want to become an active participant (and thus shape the way that the group functions), then feel free to join in - in an active capacity. last i checked, the culture of fm will be determined by its participants. it is not something set in stone.
again, welcome to this tribe - and im glad you managed to wander over to the wiki too. i think theres a website and a google-group also. have fun, h.
-
Re: On local geography
Fri, February 8, 2008 - 12:28 PMyeah, i dont know how to use those little accent marks. personally i am more of a mind not to worry about spelling and proper language use, as long as the point gets across. i dont think anyone here is actively insulting the culture of nica, which would be a different thing. its really annoying to hae to have seperate websites up for referance on how to spell something, and the names and grammar are a little different then most of us are used to :) somethings even have completely different names... should we be using lake colcibolca instead of lake nicaragua? would people know what w are talking about? if we are using 'lake', istead of 'lago', should we be calling it 'sweet water lake' as i believe the name translates to? some more effort to really learn these things would be useful though, your right. most of us, even if we spell things right, cant say them. a guide for something like that (and a limited spanish guide, as it is used there) might be a really useful thing :) also, keep in mind some people are JUST coming to the project, and it is their firsts introduction to these names... its pretty natural for people to screw up the name of a foreign landmark in a foreign language their first few times around. i havent had the heart to correct people in those cases (like i am some authority or something, ha!)
i dont think we are really going for a BWB feel here. if we were it would probably be easier ust to join BWB, or one of the local charities. local aid is one of the things we will be doing, but not as the goal of the project. honestly, if a group of rich white folk moved into my backyard when i was growing up, for 'charity' reasons, i would be insulted. we are going there to BE locals, while hopefully not intruding. think more of the relationship of BM and gerlach. we are commited to not abusing the local culture, and of not leaving a trace (as in trashing the place), and we have definetely talked about charity type work when the project starts making 'profit'; but a lot of the local outreach will be on the individual level rather then the organization level. our main goal as an org is to provide the blank canvas for others
to make their dreams come true. so for a broad goal, we have a broad vision.
there was a vision statement around at one point, not sure what happened to it (adam?). i think it seemed rather redundant with the goals, whch are essentially the same thing. the vision (paraphrasing out of memory) is to make a year round community, with the feel and spectacle of the Burningman event. the goals of the org (and the vision) are limited, because this is about individuals, not the org. the org itself really wont do a lot beyond the legal and financial points required to keep the project going. a simple goal is obtainable, a complicated one wouldnt be :) i think it is pretty clear what we are trying to do... but with some many different ideas being thrown around on here, by so many different people, it does get confusing (even more so as this is the main well of information). of course ive also been aorund since near the beginning, so of course i think its all clear :)
a local contact for more information on the volcanoes would be great. im not sure what the 'public' opinion is, i think rhino made his decision before posting anything, and no one else said much; but more information would always be great. and really, no apology needed for posting... post more! heh, its all about getting involved. if you think a small group of dedicated individuals coud make a difference in nica, BWB style, and thats what you want to see happen, then make it happen: establish a base of operations on the FM island, which would at least remove the some of the costs of living, and if nothing else you would robably have a decent volunteer group most of the time. your desire for local benefit, esspecially at this stage, would influence the entire project. if incorrect language use bothers you, correct it :) -
-
Re: On local geography
Fri, February 8, 2008 - 2:51 PMTrae:
> keep in mind some people are JUST coming to the project, and it is their firsts introduction to these names...
Well, I plead guilty of repeatedly misspelling OmEtepe.
Peter:
Welcome to the tribe, and thanks for the thought provoking comments.
Instead of a vision statement, we have a set of goals. That is on the homepage of the website, and it defines our vision.
www.floatingman.org
Harold is right, the community is going to mostly set the direction of this project. The project was initiated with the idea it's primary focus would be art and creativity. I think that's still true. But, one of our goals is living according to the 10-principles of Burningman, and those principles includes "gifting" and "civic responsibility", so I expect that the community will start taking action towards doing good work in Nicaragua.
(Note - I'd personally like to dump "Larry's" 10-principles and create our own set of values, based on what's important to us, but that's way off topic.)
Doing good in the country is important to me, and I hope that it'll be important to other people on this project too.
I don't know enough about BWB to comment too much, but it seems to me that they rush down somewhere that has had an emergency (like Peru) and start trying to fix things without taking the time to really understand the people, the culture, or what's important to the locals. Is that right?
I guess that might be necessary in an emergency (everything in life is a set of compromises), but I worry about groups that try to fix things without really knowing a country. If NGOs don't take the time to to understand the values and priorities of the people before they set out fixing things, then the only alternative is imposing our own set of values and priorities, and possibly damaging or destroying local cultures.
If I was to rate NGOs from best to worst, at the top would be the micro-loan banks who create self-reliance by helping locals build businesses according to their own visions, and among the worst are arrogant NGOs, or missionaries, who come into a country and fix things according to their own set of personal priorities. Where does BWB into under that? Where will we?
Look at the irony of "gifting" everyone private bathrooms, and destroying the wonderful spirt of community that existed around the public well.
These are the sort of topics and implications that I want to talk about within our own community. But all of this is way down the road for me. First we need to buy the island, and create our own homes.
Just because we've living on an island which gives us the privacy to throw crazy festivals, doesn't mean that we won't be interacting with the locals, and cannot venture forth elsewhere in the country to help out.
Right now, none of us know enough about Nicaragua. It's no surprise that we're butchering names. But I'm down here learning about the country, Indigo has been down here and is coming back, and hopefully more people will come down soon. How long will it take us to really get to know this country? 1 year? 2 years? 5?
At first glance down here, I've been very impressed. The locals seem very welcoming to foreigners. There is a big Nicaraguan art scene - including a Nicaraguan art commune on an island. Art and music are big priorities to the Nicaraguans. Plus the Nicaraguans love huge fireworks, and burning things. It's nice to start with some cultural similarities.
So, we're still very much in the process of learning things. We have to admit our mistakes. Learning is a good and healthy process. Feel free to correct any spelling errors we make. But hopefully after our project is settled and underway, and after we've learned _much_ more about the people, their culture, and the country, then we'll be to start doing some real good.
2 cents on that.
By the way, from the initial idea to create a permanent community somewhere on the water, we're already more than 2-years into this project. There are still some problems to be solved, but none of them seem unsolvable. And there are still many things to learn, but much of that can be learned on the island. I need to check the property title, and we need to find 92 more people. But other than that I think we're good to go.
Any questions, just let us know. -
-
Re: On local geography
Mon, February 11, 2008 - 8:36 AM
I tend to be at bit overly verbose.
Perhaps, I could sum up my previous message as simply this:
I see our role in Nicaragua as being just important to learn from the Nicaraguans, as to try to "help" them.
-
-
-
Re: On local geography
Tue, February 12, 2008 - 12:29 PMSo, thank you all for your responses, for your hospitality, and for helping me to understand what's going on here.
First, before I forget, I found my contact info at INETER. I doubt he's the right person to talk to, but he can get you talking to the right person, whereas otherwise you'd perhaps be stuck with a PR person that would just say, "oh, you have nothing to worry about." I would prefer not to post his info here, so I'll msg it to Adam (and anyone else who asks). He's German, and speaks perfectly good English.
I think it's really difficult to plan these communities because, as has been said, the planning/visioning and building a community are concurrent and inter-dependent processes. If planning lags behind community building and enthusiasm, the project end a disaster; if you make a big plan and ask people to subscribe to it, they may decline, or at best not feel they share ownership of the project. What I hear from you is that the community is still very small and new, so I'm wrong to say that there should already be such as a vision document, which is totally valid.
I grok that you're not going there to blindly "do good", and I agree that it would be ugly and foolhardy to charge into a place with that intention. Of course, you have to decide who you are and start to build a home before you could hope to turn your attentions elsewhere. But know that, even on an island, you /will/ have a relationship with local folks, and unless you integrate them tightly into your project from before day 1 (and probably even then), rumours will develop about the crazy hippies having free love parties on the island out there. Ask Bruno at El Zopilote in Madroñal, on Maderas, about that.
People will not understand what you are doing, and they will invent stories. Their opinion of you will be based in no small part on what they feel you've done for them and for their community, and the rapore you've developed with them. Given that you're talking about buying a large island off Granada, "they" refers to the people of Granada in general (Nicas and foreigners) as well as the whole South-West quadrant of Nicaragua to a lesser extent. You will struggle with this, and there is no easy solution.
Again, good luck with this. I think there will continue to be a lot of suspicion around the project which is perhaps more easily combatted in person. I'd love to talk to folks in person about what you'd like to create. If there's anyone in the Seattle area, we could get lunch or drinks or whatever. Otherwise, I suppose there'll be opportunities on the Playa.
Cheers,
Peter -
-
Re: On local geography
Thu, February 14, 2008 - 2:46 PMPeter:
Thanks for the good info and constructive criticism.
> What I hear from you is that the community is still very small and new, so I'm wrong to say that there should already be such as a vision document, which is totally valid.
I don't know if we ever will need a vision document. Outside of the goals already set, our "vision" will be the collective and organically evolving vision of all of the people currently involved in the project.
Burningman has been going for 22 years. Do they have a vision document?
> People will not understand what you are doing, and they will invent stories. Their opinion of you will be based in no small part on what they feel you've done for them and for their community, and the rapore you've developed with them. Given that you're talking about buying a large island off Granada, "they" refers to the people of Granada in general (Nicas and foreigners) as well as the whole South-West quadrant of Nicaragua to a lesser extent. You will struggle with this, and there is no easy solution.
Before coming down here, I had big fears about huge cultural gaps. Things are actually far better than I thought it would be. The Nicaraguans love art and music. They love fireworks. And there is already one island art commune in Solentiname. So, I'm thrilled to see that we are starting with some cultural similarities. But you're right, there will certainly be problems and challenges.
The island is pretty far from Granada. It's right off the coast of Chontales. Here's a link to a map. There is a chain of four island in the east side of that map. Isla el Muerto is the fourth of them.
maps.google.com/maps
The entire region of Chontales is almost untouristed and has not _yet_ had the property booms of Granada, Leon, San Juan del Sur, and Ometepe. This seems good and bad for us. It means they might be even more misunderstandings, or it might give us an opportunity to set the right impression from scratch; untainted by what other foreigners have done.
We haven't put nearly enough thought into integrating with the locals. It's something we need to start thinking more about now. I'm going to create a new thread for this topic right now.
I'm in Juigalpa, the capital of Chontales right now. I like the Juigalpa, and might move down here for a while. That'll give me more of an opportunity to learn about the local people, and their views. There is a Norweign guy who has been living in Nicaragua for 20-years who apparently comes to the same bar in the central square every afternoon. I'm going to try to find him today and see what advice he can give us.
> First, before I forget, I found my contact info at INETER.
For other people's info. This is regarding the danger of volcanoes. It's not at all my personal concern, but if someone wants more info please message me or Peter.
Peter, in your private message, you also said that you worked on an internet project on Ometepe. What can you tell us about that?
All of the hotels seems to have internet now. Were you a part of setting that up? What can you tell us about setting up an internet connection on the island? Should it be easy to do the same on our island setting up a point to point connection to Juigalpa or Granada?
> I'd love to talk to folks in person about what you'd like to create. If there's anyone in the Seattle area, we could get lunch or drinks or whatever. Otherwise, I suppose there'll be opportunities on the Playa.
Trae is in Arizona. I'm traveling between San Francisco, Nicaragua, and Europe (for work). Burningman is more than 6-months away. Will you be coming back to Nicaragua?
Other than that, join in on our next meeting. I think that'll help you get a better idea for who we are, how we work, and what we're trying to accomplish.
Or we can just schedule a time to talk on the phone. I'll try to answer any questions that you have.
Cheers form Juigalpa.
-Adam -
-
Re: On local geography
Wed, February 27, 2008 - 12:03 AMChontales, awesome. I was totally going on an assumption that it was a larger one of the isletas around Granada. I never made it out to that side of the lake, and don't know much about it.
I'm young and inexperienced. Do you need a vision document? I don't know. Maybe you just need people to spend a bunch of time together and build your community incrementally. I've been burned by lack of planning, so that's where my bias comes from.
You're totally right about there being plenty of opportunities for you to connect with Nicas on things you're both enthusiastic about. I think I just mean to say that you shouldn't let building relationships with Nicas be an afterthought to building your own community.
I spent about 18 months from 2004 to 2006 building a wireless network on Ometepe. It connects Finca Magdalena, Playa Santo Domingo, Altagracia (and proyecto Sí a la Vida), and Urbaïte to a satellite Internet connection. The project is still running, with a German gentleman having taken over the technical side and Sofia Kofler of Villa Paraïso on the business side. I really need to do a thorough write-up of what happened, what I learned, and what kept the project from being better than it could have been.
Building the network and everything that went along with it was a slow, slow process and you can expect your work to go at least as slowly. I'm sure you're well acquainted with the speed of transportation. You can imagine if you had no transportation of your own and had to keep going back to Managua whenever you needed anything. There were so many days I spent all day in transit to get one small thing done, and failed because whoever it was wasn't in, or they didn't have any of what I needed, or the power was out. You just have to come back to your hammock, replenish yourself, admire the sunset, and observe that you don't have it too bad.
You should be able to convince someone to let you set up a point-to-point radio connection between Mombacho and your island. From Google Earth it looks like it's about 40-45km, which is doable with sturdy masts, good radios, and highly directional antennas. I worked with IBW, which knew what it was doing much better than anyone else, and was based in Nicaragua. My understanding is that the company has since been sold to some Argentinians, but I assume the quality of service is still high. If the timing works out, I'd be happy to take charge of negotiating and/or building a link to the island in a year or two, at the appropriate time.
I would love to go down this summer to visit old friends and hang out. I don't know whether I'll be able to take the time off when I'm already committed to taking time off for family visits and Burning Man, but I hope so. I'd be happy to come to one of your meetings as well. I wouldn't mind popping down to the bay area for a weekend, if that's where they're held.
It must be getting to the unpleasantly hot and dry season. Stay cool, piss clear, and all that. Make it up to Miraflor, near Estelí, if you have the chance. It's very refreshing when the rest of the country is hot, and totally beautiful. -
-
Re: On local geography
Wed, February 27, 2008 - 5:25 PMPeter:
> Do you need a vision document? I don't know. Maybe you just need people to spend a bunch of time together and build your community incrementally. I've been burned by lack of planning, so that's where my bias comes from.
On the topic of the vision document, don't confuse it with planning.
We already have plans, goals, and values. I simply don't see what a 'vision document' would add. If someone can show us what value this adds, I'm willing to help write one up.
> You should be able to convince someone to let you set up a point-to-point radio connection between Mombacho and your island.
I think that things might have changed in the past couple of years. Monkey Island Hostel on Ometepe now has a point-to-point internet connection to Rivas. There is a photo of their tower right here:
www.flickr.com/photos/227...2297171470/
They certainly didn't have the technical skills to set that up. I'm under the impression that there is a company that provides this service now.
But I don't have the full details.
> It must be getting to the unpleasantly hot and dry season. Stay cool, piss clear, and all that. Make it up to Miraflor, near Estelí, if you have the chance.
I'm actually back in the US now. Got back last week. And boy was it depressing going from nice warm Nicaragua to cold and wet San Francisco.
I'm thinking of heading back pretty soon.
-
-
-