New tribe: Fallen Fruit

topic posted Thu, April 19, 2007 - 6:11 PM by 
A tribe dedicated to mapping the public fruit trees in the community, and gathering to go out fruit foraging :)

Link:

tribes.tribe.net/fallenfruit

Hope to see you there :)
posted by:
  • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

    Thu, April 19, 2007 - 6:19 PM
    What a great idea!

    I have to say this - I have never in my life heard a great idea put out to the world without someone needing to step up to tell the person posting what to "look out for" or "do in addition to" and I wanted to just state that although I know those people have the best of intentions their fears are usually just the things that keep most of us from doing anything at all. Yes you will be taking something away BUT not necessarily something that the grower would have composted. And sure it would be ALSO great if you contacted the local food bank but you are under no obligation to do so either. You CAN do what you think of doing without doing anything more. And I really wish people wanting to offer their suggestions would just go DO their own thing with that caveat. I've had far too many ideas thusly disected myself and just wanted to put that out there publicly because when people do that - they always seem to have the last word cause those of us starting ideas feel that to answer them back would be insulting - they often don't realize that their words actually tend to take a bit of wind out of the sails of some wonderful ideas - as is this one. I wish I were closer - I'd certainly participate in this one.
    • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

      Thu, April 19, 2007 - 6:28 PM
      Hey cool!

      Thanks for your nice words... I'm sure the other post meant well, it's all good!

      If you're not in the area, feel free to start your own, all you need is a web presence, could be a myspace or tribe page... and model your stuff on the organizations that are doing it in other cities :)

      yay!
    • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

      Thu, April 19, 2007 - 11:18 PM
      If you are referring to me, I will tell you that I consider your response quite rude and completely wrong. I am quite certain Jewel knows my intentions far better than you do.

      It is half baked and half witted ideas that lead to people falling flat on their faces and do more harm than good and your response makes me suspect that you fit that category.

      BTW, all things decompose on their own, they do not need help with it.

      What exactly is your problem with people trying to suggest ways to make something better, let me see, perhaps it is massive arrogance and/or insecurity that anyone who tries to help out must be trying to sink something.

      What a knee jerk response. You have a lot of nerve making such assumptions.

      Passion without common sense and intellect is tantamount to insanity, I suggest you consider it before opening that big mouth of yours again.
      • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

        Thu, April 26, 2007 - 2:17 PM
        There is a huge difference between "Have you thought of doing this" which is an addition to an idea said with respect due to the person coming up with the idea and you know, actually doing something instead of taking pot shots at the doers. I went out of my way to state that I did in fact believe that people like you saying these things had good intentions - you obviously didn't take the time to read my reply thoroughly. You know, some believe that half reading or half listening to people causes more harm than good too. I wonder if someone as knowledgeable as you still takes the time to look inward and wonder about why he is so upset by a comment like mine. Is it at all possible that it hit close to home? I mean - you told me to shut up. You made sweeping judgments about my character from a comment on a website. You present yourself as this logical thinker - do you not know the standards of logical thought? Wow - you're actions certainly were not very mature. I don't tell people to shut up - I ask them to look at their motivations for what they are saying. I would wager that I would only really want people to shut up if they are telling the truth about something I'd rather keep hidden - except that I don't actually play that way. I'm sorry also to the originator of this idea but I have to disagree with her - it isn't all good. There are some forces in the world that are more destructive than creative. And it's my view that those of us on the creative side have to form a barrier around our right to create against the fears of those who cannot. See - I managed to disagree respectfully with her and never once tell her or imply that she should shut up. But you know, I guess that's because I'm one of those bakers of half witted ideas like she is instead of the solid careful thinker of fully formed and perfect ideas and ya know - DOERS like you. Right?

        Sorry to the person starting this thread - feel free to remove my comments if you find this too inflammatory. I do apologize for hijacking your lovely idea (made real instead of stopped by fear - yes!) half-baked or not (I vote not as I do not believe that "half-baked ideas cause more harm than good) - it is courageous and lovely and I'm sorry that I have thus tainted it.
        • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

          Thu, April 26, 2007 - 2:25 PM
          Just wanted to take the sarcasm down one notch to tell you (James) and anyone else - that at one time I too was one who would piggy back other's ideas until someone told me what I've told you here. They asked these same questions and instead of aiming at them as you have with me, I chose to listen. And a wonderful thing happened - I started DOING things. Hmmm... half-baked - yup. Some of them - which is the ONLY way people do things my dear. The only way. All great artists, inventors, or anything else jumped in and did stuff. They failed MISERABLY and then they succeeded. And when you are saying things like "Half baked ideas cause more trouble than gain" or similar things - take a good close look inside - I guarantee you'll find that it's fear. And when you see it you can drop it. And when you drop it, YOUR voice can also come out and give all it's messy weird and wonderful ideas to the world.

          Sorry it has to come to a head like this, but this world really makes us terrified of our own shadows and some of us have to get mad before we get real. See you on the other side.
        • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

          Thu, April 26, 2007 - 6:10 PM
          The only fear around here is by people like you who cannot face the truth and have to spout a lot of rhetoric. Don't try to whitewash your commentary, but then I see from your other posts elsewhere that you seem to go out of your way to pick fights anyway.

          And don't try to come off with that posturing BS about being a "doer" and others who disagree with you not doing anything, that is a load of bull too.

          What kills most ideas, more than anything else, not fear, but ego. Ego of people like you who are so arrogant that they think their way is the only way and that no one else has a clue about what they are doing, yet fallen fruit is hardly a new or original idea and I am sure Jewel knows that too and is fine with it, yet you seem clueless about it. Whose idea it is or how original it is is meaningless as long as you are doing something worthwhile.

          Anyone as insecure as you mention and lacking in conviction is going to fall on their face the first time they encounter any resistence, and you can bet there will be resistence, especially in urban areas where people have been fined,cited, arrested and sued for taking things from other peoples land or the public right of way. A man in florida went to jail for feeding such things to the homeless.

          Anyone who thinks their idea cannot and should not be improved upon, especially in the early stages when it costs nothing, is a complete egotistical moron.

          Your ego keeps you from accepting that someone might be offering useful input and who may have actually done and been doing what the people are talking about but you are too arrogant to consider that option. Your comments on other peoples intentions are rude, assinine and arrogant and foolishly assumptive, in fact it reflects the typical tactic of trying to project those things onto other people.

          I'll give you a clue, last year, my people gathered and donated to the local food banks, approximately 1 ton of food per week by working with local farmers who had extra crops or who had second growth in their fields they were not going to pick. I also worked at those food banks and went to local stores to round up unused or unwanted food. And that is not the only such project we were successful at in the last few years in this area.

          Tell me, how many acres of damaged land have you reclaimed? How many acres of wetlands have you preserved? How many artificial wetlands have you constructed to control pollution? How much time and money have you donated to any form of meaningful cause?

          How many real non-profit organizations do you actually work with or serve on the board for?

          Ever worked with 4 H, scouts, project second harvest, Big Brothers and Sisters, or perhaps the American Cancer Society?

          I donated thousands of dollars last year to charitable efforts including several thousands of hours of my time and work and at least as much in additional personal expenses.

          If I take the time to offer contributing advice to a friend with similar interests it is none of your business.

          You know nothing about things I have done or am doing and that is another arrogant assumption on your part.

          Maybe I am tired of knee jerk know it all loudmouths that show up here on tribe so much.

          Maybe I am tired of all the hippy wannabee liars.

          Maybe I am fed up with twits that have to question every motivation when people try to do something nice for others and run everything into the ground. People like you are why a lot of people get fed up with trying to support good ideas.

          I have seen people like you kill of far more good ideas and efforts than constructive commentary ever will. I saw a person fitting your exact pattern of behavior cost a cat shelter I worked with a pair of fully equiped computers and monitors.

          Maybe I don't like people who question my integrity when I try to offer help to someone I considered a friend long before you show up with that silly profile picture.

          You can wager what ever you want to and you will still be wrong, and don't try the "I don't play that way BS" either since you just said it. Yeah, that's real mature.

          No you don't tell people to shut up, you just go on and on trying to imply that people who offer useful advice are trying to sink the effort.

          So why are you so paranoid and inflamatory? I see it is not just here, and you even say you go looking for fights in your profile. So you pick a tribe, try to suck up to some people then decide to incite flames from someone else. That's a real emotionally stable and mature pattern.

          OOO, "those of us on the creative side", nice attempt to instill an us against them mentality, too bad you are wrong again, so that line of bull won't fly either. I won't demean my efforts by listing them for the likes of you.

          Nobody has perfect and fully formed ideas at the start, that statement and implication is also idiotic.

          So, have you ever done anything useful or do you just go around trying suck up and hang on other peoples coat tails?

          Don't bother replying to me unless you have something mature and useful to say. I've already dealt with too many of the type you are coming across as.
          • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

            Thu, April 26, 2007 - 9:23 PM
            i think perhaps it's time to keep this personal grumbling out of the public arena, eh?! and get back to the gathering and disseminating of fruit at hand... i've got 27 varieties of apples and a few pears to boot, for any of ya'll along the coast in northern CA... contact me in the fall and maybe we'll make some butter, or cyder, or whiskey apple pie;-)
          • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

            Tue, January 22, 2008 - 12:48 PM
            2,080 hours is full time, 40 hours a week. Several thousands of hours would have to be more than two, at least four. So you donated double time. That would be most of your waking hours. If your summation of your donation to non-profits and charitable causes last year is correct, then you have donated somewhere in between 80-150,000 dollars. If that is indeed true, why so defensive?
            • Re: New tribe: Fallen Fruit

              Tue, January 22, 2008 - 9:24 PM
              Well, for what it's worth Blackberries are allllll over in the Salem, Oregon area (hell most of Willamette Valley). free for the pickin. I have a couple of my personal favorite spots. I take anyone who wants to go. I also know of a few random apple trees up in the hills of west Salem and and a bunch of Philbert trees over there too. If you all could see just how big these wild blackberries get, you'd be here too. (Low rent and the blackberries are pretty much the only reasons I stay in the ultra conservative town, really)

Recent topics in "Food Not Lawns"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
city $itation offlineLori 0 September 28, 2008
potatoes? Nadia 4 September 14, 2008
F N L website Materpiscis 0 August 5, 2008
"Turf War" by Elizabeth Kolbert in The New Yorker. July 21, 20... 0 July 20, 2008