I have yet to be pegged, but have experimented with toys and found that I am, apparently, a size queen. Is this more of a turn-on or turn-off for girls interested in pegging?
It depends on the girl, and how long you've been pegging. I would say in my case, size isn't everything for her. She likes to physically be able to handle her tool, and doesn't like going slow, so our 1 3/4 8 incher is her fave, right after the share, which is smaller.