Advertisement
Does money represent power, evil or greed?
Does your relationship with money make it harder to enjoy it? Make it? Save it? Or what?
Do you feel quilty when you make more then those who are struggling around you? Do you feel greedy when you wish you had more? Or are you completely comfortable with a large amounts of money, yet don't dare to admit it outloud....
Does your relationship with money make it harder to enjoy it? Make it? Save it? Or what?
Do you feel quilty when you make more then those who are struggling around you? Do you feel greedy when you wish you had more? Or are you completely comfortable with a large amounts of money, yet don't dare to admit it outloud....
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: money...your views
Thu, October 8, 2009 - 2:58 AM"Does money represent power, evil or greed? "
No. Money does not represent anything. It seems to be a complete illusion...a made up thing used as a method of measuring exchange and value. From what I can tell, it seems as neutral as rocks, sand, the sky and the grass.
"Does your relationship with money make it harder to enjoy it? Make it? Save it? Or what? "
My relationship with money has me enjoying it when I have it, and cursing it when I don't. It also causes me to struggle with earning it or obtaining it sometimes....
"Do you feel quilty when you make more then those who are struggling around you?"
No. Never.
"Do you feel greedy when you wish you had more?"
No. Never.
"Or are you completely comfortable with a large amounts of money, yet don't dare to admit it outloud.... "
I'll admit it aloud any time. I see no shame in having wealth. I have been wealthy (well, upper-middle-class, anyhow), and I have been poor, and I have been mostly lower-middle-class. I would prefer to be wealthy, and regardless of how much I have, I dedicate some of my time and money each year to humanitarian causes in which I believe. This alone prevents me from ever feeling guilty about how much I have. I know I'm not one of the bastards whose "humanitarian" cause is something like the Project For A New American Century...so...I have no reason to feel guilty about it when I do have more of it. -
-
Re: money...your views
Thu, October 8, 2009 - 9:33 AMTO quote Lee "SCratch" Perry--note the nickname scratch!! He says Money me a Bloodclot, and I concur!
-
-
Re: money...your views
Thu, October 8, 2009 - 10:17 AMI've never felt guilty about making more than someone else... but I've never made more than a middle-class income, which I think is something that everyone deserves. But I am aware of the fact that there are alot of people who are barely eking out a living. And if I ever made a 6 figure income working for a company that was paying other employees very little, I would definitely feel that something was wrong. I don't know if it would necessarily be guilt, but I would feel a responsibility to try to do something about it.
My attitude toward money sometimes makes it hard to save. I spend it and I'm not afraid to share it or give it away. Money, to me, seems like something that should flow pretty freely... there's plenty of it. If there's something that I want, and I'm making enough to live comfortably, give some, and save, I don't tend to have problems saving up for the thing that I want. But there have been times when it was pretty much impossible to save anything because I was just making enough to get by day to day.
My attitude toward money doesn't make it hard to make it... but my attitude toward work sometimes does. I don't believe in putting a whole lot of time and energy toward making money for someone else... to me, that's supporting someone else's success who's not doing the same for me in return. You put the majority of your waking hours toward a company for little in return... get a promotion... more responsibility and time, usually for little more in return. My time's important to me. And I'm worth more than that.
-
Re: money...your views
Thu, October 8, 2009 - 12:10 PMMoney, unfortunately, represents freedom for me. The more I have, the more freedom I have to do/accomplish what I deem important in my life. I don't feel guilty when I make it; I've worked hard for it. I don't feel greedy when I want more; I want more freedom. I get a little pissed off at myself, when I can't use my intellect to figure out how to make more money and allow myself more freedom. Money, as an abstract concept, is just another way to barter. It's not "evil," unless you'd like to characterize it as a necessary evil. Unfortunately (or, fortunately) we don't live in a simple, agrarian, world anymore. I can't just trade my legal expertise for your chicken. I save it and spend it, as I see fit. It's never really controlled my happiness. That comes from other sources. -
-
Re: money...your views
Thu, October 8, 2009 - 2:04 PMOne year (late 1990s) I grossed $32,000 which to me was an enormous amount of money. Once (1984) my wife and I bought a new Mitsubishi pickup truck for $6,000. Only new vehicle I've ever had. Now a new pickup costs $30,000.
What is middle class? Not many years ago there was a paper put out showing that 80% of the population made under $50k a year, and 50% of the population made under $30k. What was the percentage of people making under $20k? Who cares?
Half the population made under $30k so I only hit the upper half big time once in my life.
We are losing 300,000 jobs a month in this country. But it's "down" from a high of 500,000 so OF COURSE we are in a "recovery" from the 'recession" especially since Wall St is doing better after having stolen $2.2 trillion in "bail-out" extortion money from "our" representitives in DC. We have lost 11,000 jobs an hour since Dec. 2007. There are six applicants for every shit burger-flipping job in America. McDonalds isn't even hiring, and when you see 30 & 40 years olds behind the counter one has to wonder just what jobs are even open to the young.
Most of the jobs that took our grandparents or parents out of the poorhouse have been "outsourced" to dictatorships by American corporations to increase profits in the last thirty years. First to the American South, then to Mexico, then Centro America, then China, and now Viet Nam and Burma etc etc. Bluntly, it has become "fuck you america" in favor of sweatshop slave labor. Prices sure haven't gone down any with all this savings in labor costs, but the quality certainly has. Bought any dog food from China lately? Or Mexican e-coli spinach?
What does money mean? It's the difference between life and death, being warm in a room or freezing to death in winter. Between having food to eat or stealing food to eat. This country judges YOU on how much money/possessions/things you have. And only the 1% top have gained since 1980 while the rest of us are actually making LESS than we did (in buying power) in the 1970s.
We're becoming a country of mostly have-nots. The trend is not going up by the way....
Here's what just happened in one city (a snippet):
Published on Thursday, October 8, 2009 by The Detroit Free Press
Thousands Stand in Line for Help Paying Bills in Detroit
Chaos Reigns at Detroit Aid Event
by Tammy Stables Battaglia
Thousands of people swarmed Cobo Hall in chaos this morning trying to get applications for housing and utility payment assistance from the city of Detroit.
People fainted, others fought as the Detroit Police Gang Unit tried to keep people in line --- some since last night --- and in check.
"It's a disaster here," former assistant Detroit Police chief and city council candidate Gary Brown said, handing out water. "This is dangerous. Very unorganized, very dangerous."
The City of Detroit Planning & Development Department was to pass out 5,000 applications to those standing in line. But a line of people snaking back and forth inside Cobo, down Washington Boulevard and around the corner to the circular parking deck far outnumbered the applications available.
The program is part of the city's Homelessness Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Program. By 11:30 a.m., the Detroit mayor's office was asking people not to head to Cobo.
......
How many people showed up? Another snippet view:
www.wsws.org/articles/20...ad-o08.shtml
An estimated 50,000 residents of Detroit filed into Cobo Hall convention center on Wednesday seeking assistance to pay utility bills and keep from being evicted from their homes. City officials, who expected around 3,000 people to apply for the aid, were overwhelmed by the turnout.
Money is life or death. Economic reality? It's like the Republican Health Care Plan: Don't get sick, or if you do die quickly. -
-
Re: money...your views
Thu, October 8, 2009 - 2:54 PM"What does money mean? It's the difference between life and death, being warm in a room or freezing to death in winter. Between having food to eat or stealing food to eat."
Thank you... and it also often determines who you are able to be around. As they say, it's not what you know, but who you know. But people tend to hang out within their class. If you're days are spent working with other people who are doing your same job, making as little money as you are, that's who you'll get to know. And after work, if you can't afford to go to the bar, restaurant, etc., where people with more money tend to go, you're not likely to meet them. You're support system is likely to be one that offers little for resources and few, if any, connections that are really taking you anywhere. Money buys, not only resources, but also opportunity.
As Badass put it... money is freedom... this is pretty much true. So what's that make people without money? -
-
Re: money...your views
Fri, October 9, 2009 - 6:03 AMI'm still just trying to figure out what money even *is*. -
-
Re: money...your views
Fri, October 9, 2009 - 6:27 AM"I'm still just trying to figure out what money even *is*." (I think you are being rhetorical...anyway) Imagine getting recompence for your considered effort to do anything. So, when I went out to # One China Buffet with my buddy a while back, weirdly all these folks transpiring around me made me feel like I was part of a grand narrative. Every little action there was a reaction--and I like the balance of that. I had been studying my Islamic history around that point and a very homely Muslim family were sitting across from us. Really almost peasant like, and I liked the sense of that simplicity--and reasoned approach that was so different than mine, just looking at their conventions. At some point in our dinner, my friend said, Dude, youre going to get paid! And IT had nothing to do with a profession, but rather the esteem I projected would come back to me two fold. It is the "currency" of the norm that expressed my value to really a quite mundane event. This was value given to me that transcends paper money, tho' my meal was bought for me--and thus I gained recompence for good karma, I guess. -
-
Re: money...your views
Fri, October 9, 2009 - 6:40 AMscott: "This was value given to me that transcends paper money, tho' my meal was bought for me--and thus I gained recompence for good karma, I guess."
Perhaps. This is a good thing.
scott: "I think you are being rhetorical...anyway"
No, not rhetorical, but perhaps a bit metaphysical.
Obviously I know that little green pieces of special paper-type-stuff is money, but I'm still trying to understand the underlying meaning behind them. For instance, how is the purchasing power of a $1 bill determined? Who decides that? Who decides how many Japanese yen are equal to $1? How does the government "printing" money affect the value of $1? Does a change in the total amount of currency in the US change the value of 1 yen? Why?
If I raised a private army and went and invaded, say, Antigua, and created my own country and issued my own currency, how is its value determined?
Those are the sorts of questions that bother me these days. Economists tell me the answers to most of those questions are "market forces", but that's pretty much the same thing as saying "magic". -
-
Re: money...your views
Fri, October 9, 2009 - 6:43 AMI agree, Waylon. It's all "magic." That's why there REALLY is no such thing as "national debt" that our Republicans are so quick to point at as being a chain around our children's future. Bullshit! With swipe of the pen, as was evident last year about this time, debt can be created or destroyed.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: money...your views
Fri, October 9, 2009 - 5:53 PM"America touts itself as the land of the free, but the number one freedom that you and I have is the freedom to enter into a subservient role in the workplace. Once you exercise this freedom you've lost all control over what you do, what is produced, and how it is produced. And in the end, the product doesn't belong to you. The only way you can avoid bosses and jobs is if you don't care about making a living. Which leads to the second freedom: the freedom to starve. ”
— Tom Morello from the band Rage Against the Machine -
-
Re: money...your views*** Have little money, so I'll persist in the realm of the meta-physical (if I can)
Sat, October 10, 2009 - 5:36 AMBeing a student has everything to do with the "expense" of our ability to proliferate what it is that compels us to learn. So, my capital is all this ascetic derived ideation. However, usually there is NO IN for me in the human marketplace, because this stuff is conceptual and almost contrived...and yet there are two women authors whose depth with which I keep getting inundated beyond my norm. Karen Armstrong gives me fantastic dreams (her latest which I purchased (buying books is what I waste a lotta money on, say rather than going to a bar and imbibing libations) at Morris' Bookstore down the street, is called A Case for G-d), but lately I've dreamt about something Wendy Doniger related: the Horse Sacrifice. My ex's (Alison's) Mom made silks, and I've dreamt about horses, and my ex of late. According to the Brahmanas --early Hindu scripture, I think, what it is we do IN this life will be done to us in the World-To-Come. (The World-to-Come in the Book of Ethics--Talmud, is how paradise is translated. Because "paradise" sounds too much like a goal that would take us out of the temporal world, World-To-Come is the preferred statement for this sense of impermanence in the world of men/women.) If we eat rice unceremoniously now--or a fish, or a horse, they will eat us in the next world. According to the Hasidim, the animals that are our denizens surrounding us in our habituation with intercourse & ritualization with them & G-d, have the souls of our ancestors mitigated thru their sentience...which is one reason suggested in Chagall's Hasidic upbringing, why we treat all creatures with respect/halakhah (kosher). IT would be interesting to note that Judaism is an Agricultural religion--lots of harvest ideation & festivals, Christianity is Pastoral, and Islam is Urban.
-
-
Re: money...your views
Mon, October 19, 2009 - 12:44 PMOne of solzhenitsyn's characters voiced the opinion that "the rich man needs little". -
-
Re: money...your views
Mon, October 19, 2009 - 2:00 PMThat's so true - none of us need much. Needs and wants are two different things, and society will convince us all that we need far more than we actually do. If survival were the true goal, we'd be astonished at how little we need and how simply our needs can be met. It's truly far more rewarding to be able to do with less...and so freeing. -
-
Re: money...your views
Tue, October 20, 2009 - 5:44 AMThis is true. The happiest time in my life was when I was living on my boat with next to nothing. Unfortunately, life gets in the way sometimes and we have to change our situations ;) -
-
Re: money...your views
Tue, October 27, 2009 - 7:59 PMThis guy en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._S._G._Boggs and these folks www.ithacahours.com/ give me a lot to think about in any discussion about money. It seems to me that money doesn't have value unless it circulates.
-
-
-
-
Re: money...your views
Tue, October 27, 2009 - 8:09 PMTry as I might, though I have worked all my life, I've never been able to make any money. I mean, no more than it takes to support myself. And I just don't understand it. I don't think I'm a stupid person exactly, yet all around me I see people I wouldn't think are necessarily any smarter than me with a whole lot more money. I just don't understand it. Perhaps I never will. -
-
Re: money...your views
Wed, October 28, 2009 - 10:26 AMThere does seem to be some kind of subconscious law operating in me that says I can only have money if I work and/or suffer for it. I'd like to get rid of that!
I like money as a medium of exchange but I would prefer that it be "real" money, based on something of mutually agreed value (like a gold standard), and not be flickering numbers on a computer somewhere. It's convenient. I also like the idea of having plenty of money, because it is darn useful, prevents suffering (even though it might not bring happiness), very important it provides options to the person who has it, so their energy has a wider field in which to operate and they have freer choice and thus a feeling of more freedom overall. But my favorite thing about money is that it can work miracles when used properly.
I do think though that everybody should have their basic needs met and money should be for optional stuff. We've certainly discussed this at length before.
-
-
Re: money...your views
Wed, October 28, 2009 - 10:36 PMMoney is power. Money can provide security. Money doesn't buy happiness. Money may lead to shallow, sad, or crazy behavior.
-
Re: money...your views
Thu, October 29, 2009 - 12:39 PMI guess I enjoy the money in the sense I use it.. I dont try to hoard it. I make enough to keep me doing what I like to do and i try not to let the lack of money prevent me from doing what I want. If I really want to do something I will try to make it work money wise.
Amy :-)