California joins the crowd

topic posted Mon, March 10, 2008 - 5:47 PM by  Deborah
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
This is fantastic news. If you live in California, now would be a great time to give your representatives a call and voice your support. A call thanking Pedro Nava (who is introducing the resolution) would also be a good thing. :)

Anti-Real ID Rebellion Spreads to California
blog.wired.com/27bstroke6...-id-re.html

By Ryan Singel EmailMarch 10, 2008 | 6:24:19 PM

California's powerful congressional delegation needs to go back to Congress to reconsider the Real ID Act that requires states to issue driver's licenses that meet federal standards, according to the head of the California Assembly's Transportation Committee.

Assemblyman Pedro Nava (D-35) introduced a non-binding resolution to that effect Monday afternoon in response to concerns about privacy, security and the high price of the federal mandate -- which the government's most recent estimate pegs at $4 billion nationally. The feds are only ponying up a token amount of money, but say states can dip into their federal homeland security grants to help pay down the bill.

Howard Posner, a policy consultant to the Transportation Committee, said that last year the committee contemplated moving legislation to accept Real ID, but reconsidered after "looking at the cost, and the incredible inconvenience for driver's license holder and the privacy issues."

"We heard the feds had enacted this without any kind of review process or holding hearings," Posner said. "We thought someone ought to step back and see if this is the most cost effective way to secure driver's licenses."

When asked who the resolution's allies were, Posner named three groups -- the ACLU, AARP, and the conservative group Eagle Forum.

Congressman James Sensenbrenner (R-WI) added the the Real ID mandate to a must-pass defense spending bill in 2005, leaving the details to be determined by the Department of Homeland Security. After much delay, the final regulations were issued in February of 2008.

The resolution, which needs to go through a set of committees in both of California's legislative bodies before coming to a floor vote, would tentatively join California to a group of 17 states that have expressed opposition to the unfunded mandate.

Three states have outright rejected Real ID, setting up a showdown on May 11, when the federal government says it will not allow residents of Montana, Maine, South Carolina and New Hampshire to use their state I.D. cards for federal purposes.

That means that residents of those states will not be able to use their driver's licenses to board planes (they'll have to get pat-downs), and will be barred from federal courthouses or Social Security Administration buildings unless they have a passport.

California's resolution doesn't go nearly that far, since the state has already gotten the extension, but still might boost the anti-Real ID movement given the state's size, clout and dire finances.

If passed, the California resolution (.pdf), known as AJR 51, does not need the signature of California's Republican governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to go into effect.
posted by:
Deborah
SF Bay Area
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: California joins the crowd

    Tue, March 11, 2008 - 12:56 PM
    YAY for California!! I hope this continues to spread...

    Actually, as I understand it, Georgia is a non-compliance state also at this point (our governor has taken a "wait and see" atitude, wanting to ensure the privacy of Georgians, and also that the money is there to fund it), so we may be facing the "pat down" at airports after May 11 as well. I don't believe he (the gov.) has signed the waiver yet, and may not sign it, so it will be interesting to see what transpires. I may be doing a lot of driving this summer instead of flying...
    • Re: California joins the crowd

      Tue, March 11, 2008 - 2:32 PM
      The activist in me says it would be a *great* thing for Georgians to fly as much as possible during the latter half of May. I believe the Atlanta airport is the busiest in the nation. If enough people have to go through secondary screening, it could really highlight the DHS's duplicitous tactics (DHS is *hoping* for long lines so that people will clamor for Real ID). It could make DHS look bad because it's obvious that people didn't suddenly become terrorists overnight, and so DHS is wasting valuable resources in searching people who don't need to be searched.

      Having a couple of friendly press people present to interview people who comment about the bullying tactics of DHS can only help. ;)
      • Re: California joins the crowd

        Tue, March 11, 2008 - 2:38 PM
        You definitely have a good point there, Deborah. Atlanta IS the busiest airport, in the WORLD, I believe. And, having been there a number of times, at different times of day, and seeing the enormous amounts of people there at pretty much any point during the day, I can see where lots of people flying would cause quite an uproar.

        Maybe I will make some flights in May...just to see what happens... ;-)

  • Re: California joins the crowd

    Sat, March 15, 2008 - 8:31 PM
    I had thought that Texas had agreed to implement the Real ID Act but have since read that we too have taken a Wait And See attitude about it and have not agreed to anything yet.
    With any luck maybe Texas will grow a pair and stand up to the DHS. One can always hope.

Recent topics in "Real ID -- activism"