Advertisement
I really don't understand the problem here.
Why do so many finns hate Sweden?
We don't hate Finland.
I remember a certain member who was joining the Real Sweden Tribe.
The first thing he said was.............
- I joining even if it is an "enemy tribe".
Me and the moderator didn't understand a thing.
What enemy tribe? What are you talking about? Are we an enemy tribe? Then we gave him compliments about Finlands great hockeyteam. (I have always enjoyed the finnish offensive play). And when Sweden won the final i was the first one to give Finland compliments for playing great hockey.
But...........
And i don't still understand what's the problem? Can anyone explain what's wrong? Something historical?
You won't here me saying even one bad word about Finland. I have nothing against finns, and why should i?
And......finns are definitely NOT targets for racism and discrimination and ONLY live here because of they get more money. They live here because the WANT to live here, else they have moved back to Finland long time ago.
If anyone wants i can explain the current situation in Sweden quite well.
Why do so many finns hate Sweden?
We don't hate Finland.
I remember a certain member who was joining the Real Sweden Tribe.
The first thing he said was.............
- I joining even if it is an "enemy tribe".
Me and the moderator didn't understand a thing.
What enemy tribe? What are you talking about? Are we an enemy tribe? Then we gave him compliments about Finlands great hockeyteam. (I have always enjoyed the finnish offensive play). And when Sweden won the final i was the first one to give Finland compliments for playing great hockey.
But...........
And i don't still understand what's the problem? Can anyone explain what's wrong? Something historical?
You won't here me saying even one bad word about Finland. I have nothing against finns, and why should i?
And......finns are definitely NOT targets for racism and discrimination and ONLY live here because of they get more money. They live here because the WANT to live here, else they have moved back to Finland long time ago.
If anyone wants i can explain the current situation in Sweden quite well.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Fri, March 28, 2008 - 11:21 AMOne more thing Georgiane.
Does this sound logic?
Your uncle in law has lived in Sweden, for 40 long years, as a target for swedish racism and has been bad treated under those 40 years. Still, he earns so much more money in Sweden that he forces himself to stay in that pain of a country?
Sounds like a lot of bull to me, to be honest.
And, after 40 years of pain, he STILL chooses to stay in the country because "of the children". :o
They want to be target for swedisg racism and discrimination as well?
Cmon...................
I would suggests that you talk with more finns living in Sweden to find out what it's REALLY like to live here BEFORE you build yourself an HONEST opinion.
Okey?
I have both finnish friends and and finnish neighbours. If you want i can ask some of them to describe their situation in Sweden? -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Fri, March 28, 2008 - 11:29 AMAnd............i'm half finn MYSELF among many other "swedes".
One of my cousins own Haparanda loaders. Half of all my relatives are finnish but lives in both Sweden and Finland.
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Fri, March 28, 2008 - 12:40 PMYou'd think after 40 years "the children" would no longer be an issue. Wouldn't "the children" all be adults by now, and free to make their own decisions? -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Fri, March 28, 2008 - 1:21 PMAs a final comment to all this, i will quote that part i was a bit upset to read.
I'll quote you.
>> It is a wonder that Finns don't come back home from Sweden based upon the daily discrimination and racism they face there. However, they get paid a lot more there than they would in Finland and that's apparently incentive enough to stay. The relationship Swedes have with Finns is that of the oppressor. Sweden invaded Finland long ago until when Russia attacked Sweden and took it over. The Russians, unlike, the Swedes, allowed Finland more autonomy and freedom than they ever dreamed possible under Swedish control. Until finally, Finland, declared its independence in 1917. When the Swedes were in control they used something like forced conscription to make the Finns go fight the Swedish kings wars. <<
Georgiane, how about to add some real bad actions from Charles VII?
Poltava? Narva?
Or how great the russians were when they started the finnish winter war?
While you're at it, add som actions from Germany too..........
C'mon, you can't argue like that. It's 2008 and why, in the world, do you add history to justify "how bad" Sweden is? That's certanly not the proper way to argue, and the reason for several replies from me.
Do you really belive that 350.000 finns live in Sweden, only for the money? Even if they suffer from "daily racism" and discrimination because of those horrible swedes?
You can't simply be serious..............
We have.....finnish TV broadcastings, finnish radio, even finnish magazines. Most of the finns who live here don't make any big money, they work on ordinary factorys, in fact, they don't make much more money then they would make in Finland, yet they choose to stay. Perhaps they WANT to live in Sweden? Thought of that?
That was my arguments. I'll hope they makes sense.
Have a nice weekend, all of you. :)
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sat, March 29, 2008 - 2:19 AMWell, yes. but wouldn't you want to live in the same country as your children? and when it happens your grandchildren? That's is why a person would want to stay there. -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sat, March 29, 2008 - 2:46 AMI can understand that Georgiane. :)
But if the children have choosed to live here instead if Finland, Sweden can't be that awful place to live in, right?
(and belive me, it isn't)
As i said in the beginning, a Sweden without any finns, would't be Sweden.
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sat, March 29, 2008 - 3:18 AMFirst of all, I am not arguing about anything. I am only discussing issues. I am not saying my observations apply to every single Finnish person in Sweden. I am not saying my statements reflect the view of all the Finns in Finland. It seems that increasingly, Christer, you have gotten way too emotional for me. You are also taking this way too personal. So, much, so that you are asking me all these crazy things like, Have you thought of that? or, saying things like, How many Finns in Sweden to you know? etc. Uhm, I am not making things up. I am not lying. I give you references when it is necessary. However, if I am mention something I heard a few months ago, it is difficult to find the old story. Anyway, I don't think that is a way to discuss anything. That type of discussing is reminiscent of the 4th grade. Actually, creating a new thread and using my name so many times in the other ones where you systematically dismiss everything I say, well, it is like your flaming me. Especially, when you people now take the example of my Uncle in law and make a mockery of it. I mean, you asked if i talked to any Finns in Sweden and when i give you and example suddenly you start talking crap about him. Plus, you made up a lot of things about him which i never said. You take what I say and you add things to it. I read what you say and think ok, that's what he thinks. Then I talk about something else. I never slam what you say or deny there is any truth to it, nor do i demand that you give me every single resource for your statements.
So, about this special relationship you told about before between Finland and Sweden the one you said nobody outside of Scandinavia would understand... Well, they would understand it if you told them about it.That sounds highly pejorative to me. In fact, many of your statements come of as extremely pejorative. I think people outside of Scandinavia can understand the relationship. For instance, Americans, you can liken the relationship to the white folks of early America who were landed and have African slaves. So, that whole situation of slavery. The white land owners have a much different perspective and idea of the relationship they had with their slaves. On the other hand the slaves and their descendants have a very different view on the whole situation. Now, I am not saying they are identical situations. I am saying that There are two different views of the same phenomena; hear both and see what you think.
I presented a very valid view of the relationship Finland has with Sweden. Of course of course of course, duh duh duh. we could go on and on ad naseum through the whole history of Finland. However, we aren't talking about Russian history, we aren't talking about Germans in Finland. We were only talking about Swedish history with Finland and it was oppressive. Seemingly, you can't understand why there would be some resentments about this, maybe it is because you are Swedish. I am writing from the perspective of a person who lives in the country which was invaded, then forced to serve a foreign crown, their language was subdued, they were forced to learn in Swedish, they were looked at as common second class simple inferior people. Well, it does have an effect on the psyche of the people. I suppose all diplomacy aside, Sweden and Russia are the enemy. Now, this just means they were the historical enemy, not that Finland is putting up a wall around itself.
I am serious about bring this up because one cannot discount it. Of course, relations between the two countries are different now. It seems as if I don't present my whole body of knowledge on this subject you are inevidable going to pick one tiny point out and ask me if I thought about it. Let me tell you that yes I did think about it. I skim your posts and then think about some of what you said and then go back over several lectures and then some anthropological and sociological studies and history books and several sentiments i have heard from different finns and observations i have made of swedish-finns and finns etc. and then i try to represent an honest educated thoughtful post. Now, I don't read your entire post because it is so negatively and hostilely tainted that I don't want to get those bad vibes into my head.
I am not here to convince anybody to my way of thinking or to the facts I have tried to present. When I have written things it is a mix of what I think (so it may be wrapped in some way) and what I have learned (which may be mostly remembered correctly). So, the opinions may be slightly subjective and the learned bits are presented neutrally. But, holy crap, you are really trying to make me pick apart every single thing I write. I just don't have time for that crap. This is not fun for me. I am not into coming online to see this massive barrage of well why did you say this did you think of that you can't be serious about this why don't you mention that. That is ridiculous. I'd rather go to another site and play scrabulous. So, dude, I don't think I am going to put up too much longer with this because this is bull. Oh and my previous post was directed at what penny said. So, obviously, I have a deeper understanding of the reasons why a Finn who lives in Sweden would want to stay there; relationships, love, family, children, property, friends, they've gotten used to it, they really love it, all in all it's a pretty damn good place to live. Anyway, I love Sweden to and still plan on moving there for some time. Please, read what I write and not what I don't write. Holy christ, i never ever ever said sweden was a bad place to live. -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sat, March 29, 2008 - 4:35 AMHmmmmmmm
No, you need to live here to really understand the relationship between finns and swedes in Sweden. It's nothing you can read about, it's something that you have to experience for yourself. Neither can you read about the relationship between swedes and norwegians, you have to experience that as well. I couldn't imagine the situation for the black people USA in the 60's, i can read about it, but you have to "been there" to really know what's it like to be black in the 60's.
Why i got a bit sarcastic was because of what you posted.
First.......
To bring up old history it's downright silly. Oooh, the swedes was horrible 1930, and they......bla bla bla.
Well, i hate all Russians because of what they did 1734.................don't mention the Nanking massacre 1938, because of that i hate all todays people in Japan......
Please.......
Don't bring up such exemples when speaking of "todays Sweden and the finns who living in the country", okey? That was the subject, right? Perhaps you should live here for a year and see what the situation is like for yourself? It's VERY different from the 60's or the 70's for exemple, i can tell you.
Besides that, we had more wars with the danes then you can count..........
They don't bring it up, neither does we, so why should you bring up old history and tell everyone here how bad those Swedes were in the 1930's. Next time i speak with a dane, should i bring up Stockholms bloodbath 1520 and tell him that we all hate todays danes because of that?
That's why i got a bit upset.
This is history, and nothing else. We can't hate each other for all future because of history, right? If finns thinks like that, i feel kind of sorry for them. Forget and concentrate on what's now.
So, please forget history and concentrate on what's going on in todays Sweden, that would give a much better picture of what's going on here NOW!
And no, i'm definitely NOT going to put up with lots of untrue crap, get your facts right before making postings about it and claim "it's the fact".
You feel so sorry for all discriminated finns in Sweden, who are targets for swedish racism as well. And you don't understand why they aren't moving back to Finland again.
I'll quote you.............
>> It is a wonder that Finns don't come back home from Sweden based upon the daily discrimination and racism they face there. <<
That's NOT an opinion, that's a statement for something "that you KNOW it's true".
You, and all the finns have the right to think whatever you like about Sweden. It's completly okey for me if you dislike Sweden. But DON'T make any statements that isn't true.
Well, i'm kind of speechless Georgiane.
If finns see Sweden THAT negative way, i'm truly speechless.....and a bit sad at the same time. I really hope that's not the situation.
Did i get too emotional?
Yes, i do, when you presents "facts" that is not true. You have all rights in the world to say what you think, but never claim it's a fact.
Sometimes i make use of some sarcasm to show you my point, that's makes it very clear, doesn't it? If you let the situation "speak for itself" you can see that finns in Sweden aren't targets for "daily racism and discrimination". Else they would taking the boat back to Finland again because they don't make much more money here then in Finland, it's that simple. -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sat, March 29, 2008 - 5:04 AMI'll better add.............
You will find single cases of discimination for ALL groups of people in Sweden, even for swedes. That's nothing new or unusual in Sweden or any other country for that matter.
And, you don't have to wonder anymore.
Now you know why all those finns aren't home yet, they want to live in this country. They are welcomed to stay as long as they like and they are also free to leave Sweden and take the boat back to Finland whenever they like. It's not exactly a long trip back to Finland. ;)
:) -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sun, March 30, 2008 - 1:27 AMGeorgiane, i know what the problem is.
You aren't finn and you don't know the "finnish mentality" in Sweden. That explains why you argue like that. I should have thought of that from the beginning instead of getting upset.
You wouldn't hear a finn discuss like that. First of all, you must know how finns behave in Sweden. "The finnish mentality".
Finns ALWAYS thinks that Sweden is no good, and Finland is so much better, in fact, everything in Finland is better from the language to the food. You will not find any more patriotic people in Sweden, then finns. An older man said to me, you MUST learn finnish, it's a great language, then he explained to me how awesome everything was in Finland, he was swedish citizen since almost 50 years. :D
The finnish mentality is much stronger among older finns the younger finns in Sweden.
Even i they like to live in Sweden (and most of them do) they are still going to tell you how much better Finland is. And, they are going to complain about every little thing they don't like in Sweden, often things they never would complain about in Finland. We Swedes are used to it and don't think it's strange. It's their mentality. They know it, we know it.
As with our other scandinavian neighbours we have a kind of hate/love relationship with finns. We make fun of norwegians, danes and finns, and they make fun of us. Heard of all the norwegian jokes in the 80's for exemple? They had their sweden jokes. Norwegians were extremely stupid and there were plenty of jokes about that. In Norway, swedes were stupid and they told lots of sweden jokes.
Back to finns..........
In other words, for most of the time you CAN'T take literally what finns say, you must understand WHY they are saying it. After 40 years i don't think that your uncle in law dislikes Sweden, i think that he actually likes to live here, and besides that he's used to it after 40 years in this country and has becoming an integrated finn/swede, else he had been back in Finland a long time ago, especially when it's not far away.
The situation in Sweden in the 60's and 70's was very different from now. Those finns have becoming integrated swedish citizens under that time, and we swedes thinks of them, as finn/swedes. They even have their own dialect. Besides that, finns are nothing new to swedes, we have had a loooooong time contact with our neighbours in the east for thousand of years. Far north people are kind of swedish/finnish, like in Haparanda, all my relatives on my fathers side speaks both languages and lives in both countries.
The immigrants we recive these days from other countries around the world is something completly new to us, and a big culture shock. Even danes and norwegians feels a bit more strange then finnish immigrants because of the long time contact.
So, next time you speak with a finn i Sweden, remember what i just said, it's their mentality, and nothing strange. You can't take their words literally for most of the time.
Don't you think it's a bit strange that a person who have lived in Sweden for 50 years complains about it and explains to you how much better everything in Finland is? ;) :D
Even if a finn lives 60 years in Sweden, he's always going to be finn and explain to you how much better Finland is, it works that way. And that's the finnish mentality in Sweden, you have to be either finn or swede to understand that. I don't know the swedish mentality in Finland, but i know the opposite very well. Let me tell you that we have plenty of great finns in Sweden who have done much for this country and finns are definitely not daily targets for discrimination and swedish racism, not as a group, single cases of some sort of discrimination happens to ALL people living in sweden, swedes are no exception.
To fully understand the situation between swedes and finns in Sweden, you must live here and experience the situation for yourself.
Does that make things more clear? -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sun, March 30, 2008 - 3:12 AMAlles klar, Herr Kommissar. Aber, this is quite annoying that you continue to ask me these jejune questions. it continues to feel like the defense of a thesis. Anyway, please stop worrying about the capacity of my understanding. I assure you, I am not that much of an idiot. I can also say that I have no firm set convictions about the whole issue. I have said and it is obvious that I am experiencing this as an outside observer in the country amongst the people who were oppressed. That is to say what I have been doing is participant observation in Finland. It is extremely obvious that in order for me to get whole picture, I would have to live in Sweden which I said I would do. Like, I already said that. I have a degree in anthropology. So, I think about things using a mosaic approach; meaning that I consider an array of disciplines through which I can formulate my thoughts on a subject. I do take into account a great number if things; from they psychological aspects, to social studies, to religion, linguistics, history, art, etc. So, as I have examined the dynamics of other societies, I am bound to do a cross-cultural comparison. Really, you don't have to go on trying to educate poor little clueless me, because if I had the time, I would go read a book or some actual studies, rather than take your subjective view of the situation. I think the relationship between Finland & Sweden can be looked at within the framework of post-colonial theory. The statements you make still sound extremely nationalistic to me. It seems to me that you take a rather universalistic approach while I more inclined to relativism. However, maybe is this form of communication (a thread) that makes it appear so. I don't think there is a problem that either of us have. We are just two different people from two different backgrounds and perspectives with two different ways of explaining ourselves. I don't even think we are talking about the same thing, because this conversation has gone all over the map. Or maybe we are talking passed each other. Yeah, so back to scrabulous. -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sun, March 30, 2008 - 4:25 AMJa ja, alles gut!
A small tip!
Some things is hard to read about, you must simply "be there" to understand "what it's like", and "how things really work", no matter how educated you think that you are.
Then we can see this discussion as finished, i suppose.
Haben Sie einen schönen Tag!
-
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sun, March 30, 2008 - 2:32 PMNow it's time for you two to kiss and make up. -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Sun, March 30, 2008 - 9:27 PMWell, all i do is presenting facts of the real life here. And if someone gets annoyed by that, it's their personal problem. :)
-
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Mon, March 31, 2008 - 1:21 AMYou've just completely misread the situation and whatever I said. So, I am not annoyed by what you think about the situation in sweden, or what you said about your real life situation there. What is annoying is when you say things personally to me that are not about the issue of life there but about how you are treating me here in these threads. You have said some insulting things to me or have put them in such and insulting manner. You made it personal by the way you form your statements. Especially like your so called hint a few posts up. A hint is supposed to be covert, indirect, and helpful, much like the many hints i have dispersed within the posts i have written; those which you have apparently not picked up on. So, that is not actually a hint but an overt insult. After all of what I have explained to you, you just absolutely don't get it. It must be a language barrier. Or, it just may be that you do and are really mean and want to say rude things to me on purpose.
You wrote this: Some things is hard to read about, you must simply "be there" to understand "what it's like", and "how things really work", no matter how educated you think that you are.
I respond like this:
What I wrote is only describing to you that i have a theoretical framework in which i can understand that situation there when I am there. That is the whole principle behind social anthropology. So, basically, I have been saying something similar to your lame hint. Still, I think you can get some idea about a situation from a book or a good research study.
You don't have to write to me such and inflammatory sentence like "no matter how educated you think you are." You just should write what you think, something like 'come off it you stupid bitch, you don't know shit.'¨I mean, why disguise it. Then again, maybe you are just patronizing (& don''t realize it) and you are thinking oh poor silly girl is so confused let me give her a hint on how to get along in the world so she doesn't get herself into trouble again. Is that what you think? Or do you know realize how you sound? This really feels like a playground shouting match, rather than a fair civilized discussion. Alles ain't gut.
You know, I presented some facts of real life there, which i have heard fist hand (granted, only a few people) and from second hand through the newspaper. I did reads some back ground on the issue in the EU website, too. So, why is what i said of so little value, that you dismiss it entirely. Additionally, up until this point, I have been trying to do so very diplomatically. I suggest if you really need to say anymore about this to pm me. Clearly, we are not contributing anything of relevance to this topic except that, very amusingly, we are highlighting the endemic situation that some people in Sweden and some in Finland do not agree on the type of relationship the two countries have. -
-
Re: Sweden & Finland!
Mon, March 31, 2008 - 2:21 AMWell, look for a PM in your inbox. :)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-