Why didn't she just ask?

topic posted Mon, April 21, 2008 - 11:24 AM by  Donna
Hi everyone. Okay, I know that teenagers are a peculiar sort (at least to us adults), but sometimes I truly don't understand what makes the (at least the female sort) "go around the block to go next door". My dsd is currently grounded until May 1. She got grounded - initially - as explained in my "...Stealing..." post and managed to rack up 3 more weeks (issued by me, mom, then dad) in 2-3 days.

So, last week was our week again for her. All went relatively well - no lies, no stealing, and only moderate attitude. Then, yesterday she got all moody about being grounded. I asked her what the problem was and why she was so moody. She started lamenting how unfair it was that she was grounded and started crying. I explained how much time was left and showed her on the calendar how the weeks were shown and that she was a little more than 1/2 way done. I asked her if she understood that mom, dad and I were not the bad guys, and that she was the one to choose the consequenses - she said yeah, but kept crying.

So, totally frustrated by the outburst, I pretty much begged her to tell me what the issue was now and why she was crying. She yelled at me that it was her friend's birthday and that she was mad at her because she couldn't even call her to tell her happy birthday. Well, now I finally go somewhere. So, I asked her if she asked her dad if she could have a 5 minute call to tell her friend happy birthday. I figured that maybe she did and was told no, which would somewhat explain the outburst from her. She said no.

So then I told her that it wasn't worth giving me a headache for something that a calm, logical, and respectfully asked question could solve. I told her to pull herself together, and take five minutes to call her friend.

Is this demonstration typical of most teenage girls? I can't measure by my upbringing as mine was not normal to say the least, so I flew as far under the parental radar as possible. She is definitely a drama queen, but really, is this normal? Can any of you tell me how to recognize the situation and how I can try to head it off in the future? I tried several times throughout the exchange to ask what was wrong, but to no avail. Is there something (a clue, maybe) that I could have missed?

She knows that her dad and I will usually give an inch if asked reasonably and she doesn't abuse our consideration, so I don't get what the drama was for.
posted by:
Donna
Milwaukee
  • Re: Why didn't she just ask?

    Mon, April 21, 2008 - 3:27 PM
    My fourteen year-old daughter by marriage would have done the same sort of thing. The sixteen year-old wouldn't have spoken to me. My 20 year-old would have slammed a lot of doors. My son would have slammed other things. Teenagers are majorly melodramatic. I was when I was a teen, too, as I recall. I think it's the nature of the beast.
  • Re: Why didn't she just ask?

    Mon, April 21, 2008 - 5:13 PM
    I guess I'm just old-school. There isn't much revision on an initial punishment for me.....except on grounds for good behavior. If you have an attitude dealing with a restriction that you earned for things you did/didn't too, then there is no way I'm going to consider tapering it down for my kids. Restriction sucks, that's supposed to be the idea so that you don't do the same action again and end up back on it.

    But then again, I'm not dealing with teenagers yet......my time will come and then I will come to you wise ones for answers. :-)
    • Re: Why didn't she just ask?

      Tue, April 22, 2008 - 6:03 AM
      I don't bend much at all with punishments - my personal opinion is that you earned it, you serve it. But, for a teenage girl, five minutes on the phone is pretty much an impossible mission so I didn't see it doing much damage. Plus, I'd want to be able to wish my friend a happy birthday - she was probably looking for me to bend more and give her an hour to see her friend, but that wouldn't happen.

      People try to remind me to pick my battles. My answer is that I have more than enough to choose from - seriously.
      • Re: Why didn't she just ask?

        Tue, April 22, 2008 - 10:30 AM
        And besides, 5 minutes on the phone for a teenaged girl is hardly enough to say, "Hello. Happy birthday. Good bye." Remember all the gossipy things about what happened at school, who is seeing whom, and what else is going on that really need to be said, too.
  • Re: Why didn't she just ask?

    Fri, April 25, 2008 - 7:33 PM
    Hormones and pride :)

    Most teenagers don't know how to communicate effectively. On top of that, they assume that you "just won't understand" regardless of what the problem is.

    It may have have embarrassed her that she couldn't not call her friend and didn't know how to tell you that. The waterworks may heve been her way of saying "this is really important to me".

    It sounds like you are pretty well balanced. There is nothing wrong with showing her that since she's had good behavior (during the time she's been grounded) that you can give her a break. It'll help to build her character and show that you are reasonable.

    Kudos to you for "peeling the onion" and getting her to *say* what she was thinking and feeling!


    Good luck to you Donna! =)
    • Re: Why didn't she just ask?

      Sun, April 27, 2008 - 12:25 AM
      Getting them to communicate to that point, however, can be such a challenge! The youngest was in melt-down on the way howm. She hadnt stayed in touch, today, about her location at the Renaissance Faire. She wants us to assume that if she's not in our Guild Yard, she is with her booth, but when her father checked her booth, neither she, no the owner's son were there. An hour later, they were back, but there were still no straight answers abot where they
      d been. Limits were placed upon how long she could work at the booth for the rest of the day. She didn't retturn to the guild yard at the end of those limits, and so tomorrow, she will not be working in the booth. She may try again, next week.

      So when we stopped for dinner on the way home, this immediately became, "Dad & Deena are mad at me because i was trying to help!"

      No, honey. We're upset that you didn't communicate well about where you were and with whom. We didn't know where you were, and we were worried about you. The problem is that you failed to communicate your intentions.
      • Re: Why didn't she just ask?

        Mon, April 28, 2008 - 10:33 PM
        I'm speaking from a step-child's standpoint. Mom's on her 4th marriage, divorced first when I was 5. So I'm on the other side of the fence. Just sharing what I felt, at that time.

        Best of luck to you, Deena. It's not easy.

        I only wish I knew then what I know now...

Recent topics in "*Step Families*"