Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky, considered a top Torah sage of the generation in the hareidi-religious community, issued a Jewish legal decision banning the employment of Arab workers by Jews according to the Yom Chadash daily.
The rabbi issued the decision at a meeting with several administrators of yeshivas (seminaries) in B’nei Brak. The administrators each employ an older Arab man who they do not suspect of any involvement in terrorism. The administrators decided, nonetheless to seek halachic (Jewish legal) guidance following reports that the terrorist who carried out the massacre at Jerusalem’s Merkaz HaRav Yeshiva had been hired as a driver on occasion.
“According to Jewish law, it is completely forbidden to hire Arabs, especially in yeshivas,” Rabbi Kanievsky said. “There is a concern of endangering lives.”
The rabbi continued, explaining, “After all, we are at war with them…and are there not Jews that can work and make a living?”
Asked later if his words should be publicized, Rabbi Kanievsky said: “Certainly,” according to the News First Class site.
Rabbi Kanievsky went even further, saying that Jews should refrain from employing any non-Jews, not just Muslim Arabs, and instead grant livelihood to Jews, unless there exists a huge disparity between the labor costs.
The rabbi's family told Arutz-7 that the Yom Chadash report is 100% accurate and explained that "although there can be financial justification for hiring foreign workers, G-d forbid should we hire Arabs. We are at war with them."
Rabbi Kanievsky is one of the most recognized authorities in hareidi-religious society. He is the son of the Steipler Rebbe, Rabbi Yisrael Yaakov Kanievsky, and the son-in-law of Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, the leader of Lithuanian Hareidi Jewry.
Jewish Labor Hotline Set Up
For several years, a revival of the concept of Avoda Ivrit – Jewish labor – has been taking place in the Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria regions – particularly in hilltop communities. The concept was touted by Labor Zionists in the pre- and early state eras as an important Jewish and Zionist value in reconnecting to the land and being truly independent. Though a web site listing Jewish labor businesses was closed down by the supreme court after a law-suit from an Arab advocacy group funded by the New Israel Fund, a new hotline and email account has been set up to provide Avoda Ivrit solutions.
The hotline allows consumers to receive a list of businesses in a particular field that only use Jewish workers. People are also encouraged to submit the names of such businesses to the hotline.
The hotline, for everything from gardeners, heavy equipment operators, painters, cement mixers and handymen to catering and restaurants, can be reached at: 1 599 588 588 or by emailing: mokedai@gmail.com . To reach a human hotline operator, dial extension 1, Sunday through Thursday, 8am-1pm.
An Avoda Ivrit blog also exists to promote Jewish labor.
The rabbi issued the decision at a meeting with several administrators of yeshivas (seminaries) in B’nei Brak. The administrators each employ an older Arab man who they do not suspect of any involvement in terrorism. The administrators decided, nonetheless to seek halachic (Jewish legal) guidance following reports that the terrorist who carried out the massacre at Jerusalem’s Merkaz HaRav Yeshiva had been hired as a driver on occasion.
“According to Jewish law, it is completely forbidden to hire Arabs, especially in yeshivas,” Rabbi Kanievsky said. “There is a concern of endangering lives.”
The rabbi continued, explaining, “After all, we are at war with them…and are there not Jews that can work and make a living?”
Asked later if his words should be publicized, Rabbi Kanievsky said: “Certainly,” according to the News First Class site.
Rabbi Kanievsky went even further, saying that Jews should refrain from employing any non-Jews, not just Muslim Arabs, and instead grant livelihood to Jews, unless there exists a huge disparity between the labor costs.
The rabbi's family told Arutz-7 that the Yom Chadash report is 100% accurate and explained that "although there can be financial justification for hiring foreign workers, G-d forbid should we hire Arabs. We are at war with them."
Rabbi Kanievsky is one of the most recognized authorities in hareidi-religious society. He is the son of the Steipler Rebbe, Rabbi Yisrael Yaakov Kanievsky, and the son-in-law of Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, the leader of Lithuanian Hareidi Jewry.
Jewish Labor Hotline Set Up
For several years, a revival of the concept of Avoda Ivrit – Jewish labor – has been taking place in the Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria regions – particularly in hilltop communities. The concept was touted by Labor Zionists in the pre- and early state eras as an important Jewish and Zionist value in reconnecting to the land and being truly independent. Though a web site listing Jewish labor businesses was closed down by the supreme court after a law-suit from an Arab advocacy group funded by the New Israel Fund, a new hotline and email account has been set up to provide Avoda Ivrit solutions.
The hotline allows consumers to receive a list of businesses in a particular field that only use Jewish workers. People are also encouraged to submit the names of such businesses to the hotline.
The hotline, for everything from gardeners, heavy equipment operators, painters, cement mixers and handymen to catering and restaurants, can be reached at: 1 599 588 588 or by emailing: mokedai@gmail.com . To reach a human hotline operator, dial extension 1, Sunday through Thursday, 8am-1pm.
An Avoda Ivrit blog also exists to promote Jewish labor.
-
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Tue, March 18, 2008 - 7:20 AMThis is one of the best decisions that the leaders of worlds Jewry could have made, everyone should adhere to this. This war is not one of government vs government. It is a war of people vs people. A War of biblical proportions. Good vs Evil -
-
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Tue, March 18, 2008 - 3:01 PMA Palestinian Authority Arab was arrested by IDF forces on Tuesday morning for stabbing his Israeli employer three months earlier, according to the Bethlehem-based Maan news agency. The man, 23-year-old Ahmed an-Najjer, was arrested in a village east of Tul Karem.
An-Najjer and a 20-year-old colleague stabbed their Israeli employer following a work dispute. The two believed they had murdered their victim, but the employer survived the attack. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Fri, May 9, 2008 - 8:47 AM"War of biblical proportions. Good vs Evil"
does this apply to all Jews and Muslims? -
-
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Fri, May 9, 2008 - 6:06 PM
Where's his Torah citation to prove his point? -
-
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Sat, May 10, 2008 - 3:22 PMhis " torah citation" is in saving lives. Life in judaism is to be protected and cherished, unlike in the Islamic/Arab culture who reveres the dead and encourages youth to kill themselves in battle. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Sat, May 10, 2008 - 3:25 PMi'll take that as a 'yes'
-
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Sat, May 10, 2008 - 3:47 PM
In the short term, his "torah citation" (of which I have not been able to find any reference) will save a few individual lives when one of the terror groups uses any weakness to act - but in the long run it costs many, many more lives because his ideas, his "torah citation" only is forming a greater gulf between the two sides.
Duke - Israel has peace with Jordan and Egypt. Peace is possible. There are what.......five and some million Jews in Israel? Right? Surrounded by 100million? Seems to me like a workable peace is a necessity. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Top Hareidi Rabbi Bans Arab Labor Following Merkaz HaRav Attack
Sat, May 10, 2008 - 10:13 PMwell Yehudi I must say that although it is disturbing and incorrect
(Islam does not revere death) I do find your blatent racism refreshing for its honesty. -
-
Unsu...
unless you are Palestinian
Mon, May 12, 2008 - 12:30 PM"Life in judaism is to be protected and cherished"
"The United Nations is demanding an investigation into how the Israeli military killed one of its Palestinian schoolteachers by blasting open the front door of her Gaza home with explosives in the presence of three of her children. Thirty-four-year-old Wafer Shaker al Daghma was killed last week as she stood preparing to open the door of her home to the Israeli troops. She was a teacher at a local UN Relief and Works Agency elementary school. Meanwhile, hundreds of thousands of Gazans are without power today after Gaza officials were forced to shut down the region’s only power plant because Israel hadn’t provided enough diesel to run the plant."
www.democracynow.org -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: unless you are Palestinian
Tue, May 13, 2008 - 10:32 PMposting a liberal biased article about the Israeli gov't has nothing to do with whether Judaism Values life or not. The Israeli gov't does not represent Jewish Values.
The Rabbi who is calling on businesses to stop hiring Arabs is concerned for Jewish lives because of the war that is taking place between two peoples right now. Jews vs Arabs. Liberally minded people might have a hard time with this concept seeing as they are idealogically attached to everyone being good, or at least having the potential to be good. However the evidence shows contrary to this belief. The evidence shows the majority of Arabs and Muslims supporting terror against the west, Israel and Jews. The evidence shows Israeli Arabs observing "nakba" not apprieciating all of the amenities that the Israeli Gov't provides them over the Arab gov't counterparts in other countries. So there is a war, between two people, and certain people are not afraid to admit this and act accordingly to protect their own people. -
-
Unsu...
Re: unless you are Palestinian
Wed, May 14, 2008 - 7:18 AMI understand that the actions of the Israeli gonvernment have nothing to do with Judaiam.
Shame that you don't understand that the actions of suicide bombers has nothing to do with Islam.
"The evidence shows the majority of Arabs and Muslims supporting terror against the west, Israel and Jews."
Wrong. It's propoganda and fear that shows that. And maybe a guilty conscience.
"So there is a war, between two people, and certain people are not afraid to admit this and act accordingly to protect their own people."
I have heard Palestinians who feel unjustly oppressed say EXACTLY the same thing. -
-
Unsu...
Re: unless you are Palestinian
Wed, May 14, 2008 - 7:23 AM
PS
you really seem to be racially charged against Arabs.
you know, of course, that Arabs make up less than 20% of the global Muslim population?
oh yeah, yehudi, how are things in colorado?
-
-
Re: unless you are Palestinian
Wed, May 14, 2008 - 11:09 PMI haven't lived in Colorado for 5 years. I chose to make Aliyah to Israel and support my people and my country by living here. For 2000 years, more than 600 years before the creation of Islam, Jews have been praying for our return to Jerusalem. We have had a continuous presence in the land for over 3000 years. Finally Hashem has opened the gates for our return to the land, Jews are coming by the hundreds every week from all over the globe, all with the desire to be home. This tribe is not about hate, this tribe is about being proud to be Jewish, and being proud to live as a Jew in Jewish land. -
-
-
Unsu...
Re: unless you are Palestinian
Thu, May 15, 2008 - 7:56 AMps
when you were here as Yehudi you were in Colorado and getting online during Shabaat~
that was just within the last six months, let alone five years -
-
Unsu...
Re: unless you are Palestinian
Thu, May 15, 2008 - 10:01 AManyway
i'm making myself ill trying to balance you out.
it is the type of pride that says "i am better than you",
be it racial, national or even religious, that is the reasoning behind genocide and oppression.
i am of the belief that the G-d of Abraham (saw) is the G-d of both Judaism and Islam. this is my only hope for any real harmony and lasting peace between the two groups. may we all sincerely seek to understand the Revealed Texts and live accordingly.
no peace without justice. no justice without mercy. no mercy without compasssion. no compassion without love. no love without truth.
Hashem guide, protect, and have Mercy upon us all~
Amin -
-
Re: unless you are Palestinian
Mon, June 2, 2008 - 4:02 AMYou are so spiritual,
that in spite of your anti-Jewish reactions,I started to like you,man... :)
u know,u are acting rather aggressive way in the posts,
I`d like just to say something..
I believe,u understand me as you seem to be rather smart ...
When your (your ppl`s) blood flows,
especially when it is innocent,
it aches,dear...
That is why he also was so reactive about hiring arabs in Bne Brak as
I have been myself often to Bne Brak and I see mainly only Arab workers there,
who unfortunately once (God save!) may appear to be terrorists...
We have nothing against arabs as people,
u know that well,
but we love our own people
and want to defend...
and sometimes we have that mood to express our radical thoughts,
as we all have such,
u know,I know...
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-